Audrey's profile

Audrey's reviews

  5  
Audrey has 35 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Audrey's qualities as told by our client reviews: great negotiation, well-prepared, stress-free process, supportive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Found our forever home and closed in 5 weeks with Audrey!
about 1 month ago
Found our forever home and closed in 5 weeks with Audrey!

Audrey was recommended to us by friends who worked with her to buy their house, and we're so grateful they did! She made every step of the process as smooth and stress-free as possible. And yes, we found our forever home in New Egypt and closed in 5 weeks! Being first-time buyers, it was huge weight off our shoulders to know that we could rely on Audrey and her expertise to make buying house a really enjoyable experience. She is a commensurate professional as well as an amazing (and responsive!) communicator who always kept us apprised of where we were during closing. Audrey moves quickly and is decisive, so we knew we were always in good hands with her since we could trust her to put our best interests forward. She was always there to answer questions and provide support, plus she works incredibly well with everyone else involved in our transition. There was more than one occasion where we'd say, "wow, Audrey thought of everything!" She is truly a rare gem that anyone buying a home would be so lucky to work with, and we cannot recommend her highly enough! Although she began as our realtor who helped us find our dream home in a challenging market, we now consider her our friend for life! Do yourself a favor and call her today — nobody is better than Audrey Callahan (a.k.a. the Queen of New Jersey Real Estate)!

Seller review
Best realtor
5 months ago
Best realtor

Audrey is an amazing realtor- very understanding and truly went above and beyond to make the process smooth and stress-free. Highly recommend!!

Seller review
Selling and buying
10 months ago
Selling and buying

Audrey helped me sell my house and get top dollar. She also helped find me a new home. Throughout the process she was by my side encouraging me, consoling me, making me laugh when I felt like crying. I couldn’t have asked for a better realtor to see me through a very difficult time in my life

Buyer review
Audrey Callahan is the absolute best real estate professional around, and we couldn’t be more gratef
12 months ago
Audrey Callahan is the absolute best real estate professional around, and we couldn’t be more gratef

Audrey Callahan is the absolute best real estate professional around, and we couldn’t be more grateful to her for helping us find not only our first home, but our dream house. We were referred to Audrey by friends who also purchased a house in Ocean County. After our introductory call, we know she was the right person to guide us through this crazy 2025 market — and boy, did she deliver. Within one week of signing with Audrey, we were under contract AND even out of attorney review. We closed inside of 5 weeks! Who does that in this market? Only Audrey! Audrey is a commensurate professional whose years of experience provided invaluable insight into the home buying process. She is confident and decisive, and I cannot stress enough how reassuring that was these past few weeks. Although we were initially concerned being so green as first-time buyers, Audrey made us feel empowered and excited about the decisions we made along the way. She is the epitome of a real team player who is sincere and professional toward everyone involved in our deal, which meant a lot to us because we wanted good vibes the whole time. Besides the incredible timeline that helped us find our new home in time to enjoy all the summer holidays, Audrey made every step of the way smooth and stress free. She is an exceptional communicator who is always reachable and happy to answer questions, and she’s the kind of person who will call you first thing in the morning to make sure you have everything you need. I love that she will pick up the phone to have a conversation with me instead of just pushing details through texts or emails. That’s the kind of personal touch into her work — you don’t see that kind of thing these days! I highly recommend Audrey to anyone who is ready to start searching for a home. Her expertise is unmatched, and her enthusiasm is a breath of fresh air. We’re totally Team Audrey — and you should be too!

Seller review
Fabulous to work with!
over 1 year ago
Fabulous to work with!

Audrey did a great job. She was very thorough and kept us updated all the way through the process. I would highly recommend her.

Seller review
More Than a Realtor—A Trusted Friend for Life
over 1 year ago
More Than a Realtor—A Trusted Friend for Life

Audrey Callahan isn’t just a realtor—she’s become a cherished family friend. She helped my sister find her forever home back in 1990, and over the years, her dedication, professionalism, and genuine care have left a lasting impact on our family. Audrey works with excellence and integrity, always going above and beyond to ensure her clients feel supported and confident throughout the process. Her knowledge of the real estate market is unmatched, but it’s her personal touch and unwavering commitment to her clients that truly set her apart. If you’re looking for someone who will treat you like family while providing top-notch real estate expertise, Audrey is the one you want by your side. —Donna A

Buyer review
Audrey Callahan
over 1 year ago
Audrey Callahan

We enjoyed working with Audrey. She was friendly, paient and helpful..Very copentent and professional If i need a realator in the future I will use Audrey again, as well as recommending hre to a friend..Paul and Sandra Hendricks

Seller review
Great Agent
over 1 year ago
Great Agent

I have used Audrey for the second time. She is the best. So experienced and knowledgeable. She always goes above and beyond. Great marketer. She made a stressful situation so much better. I highly recommend her. You won’t be sorry!

Seller review
Top Tier Experience
almost 2 years ago
Top Tier Experience

Audrey is one of the most knowledgeable, confident, and efficient people in her field. Because of her my experience was less hectic and successful

Buyer review
Excellent!!!
almost 2 years ago
Excellent!!!

Audrey goes above and beyond as your Realtor. She's helped me with so much to find my perfect place. She is the one you need.!!!

Buyer review
Excellent service
about 2 years ago
Excellent service

I found her to be very knowledgeable of her job. Very efficient took great pride and seriousness in her work. Always made herself available to assist in whatever issues we had to encounter. Fulfilling in areas of concern not readily known to seller.

1 - 12 of 35
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent