Arthur Donnelly

Arthur Donnelly

Licensed Real Estate Agent at Coldwell Banker American Homes
  •   5   (6 reviews)

About Arthur

My goal is to provide you with resources, information, and perhaps a little advice that will make all the difference for you when you’re buying or selling your next home. If at any point, you have questions or would like to discuss your particular needs, please feel free to reach out. I love hearing from my neighbors; their stories, aspirations, concerns, and wishes when it comes to our community and local real estate. I’m happy to share my experiences and expertise in the hopes that it may be of value to you. My family and I have lived here all our lives. I grew up in St. James, attended St. Anthony’s HS and Stony Brook University. I married my college sweetheart Ann, and we owned our first home in Selden until our growing family needed more space. In 1987 we moved to Mount Sinai with our three girls, who against all my wishes, went ahead and grew up anyway: now to be fabulous young women with families of their own. Professionally, I bring 35 years as a professional designer, home builder, renovator, and realtor to the table. I know homes in and out, but more importantly, I understand that a home is so much more than its physical elements and amenities. It’s a place where we build our lives. It’s where we create cherished, life-long memories that we hold so dearly in our hearts. It’s the sanctuary and comfort we crave at the end of the day, and it’s the pride and joy of something we’ve created, it speaks of who we are. I believe that as a realtor it’s my job to uniquely represent each one of my clients in the transfer of what many would consider their most valuable cherished asset. I see it as my job to build the right plan to guide you through the process, to protect you from any pitfalls along the way, and negotiate on your behalf. Every client is unique in their hopes and dreams. Whether you’re buying or selling, I pledge to utilize all my past experiences, my talents and tools at hand to help deliver on your dream. My mission has always been to make a difference in someone’s life today, and I keep that as a primary focus each and every day. Over the years I’ve done it through clients homes I designed and built, I’ve done it through my church and through charitable organizations such as Habitat For Humanity, Rebuilding Together, The Make A Wish Foundation, and others. My mission has become my legacy, and my legacy is that collection of memories created and cherished in the homes of my clients; the newlyweds first dinner, baby’s first steps, family game nights, holiday traditions, birthday celebrations, weddings, anniversaries, and all the little moments that will tie them all together while under that roof. My mission is to serve in ways that will deliver long, long after the transaction has been forgotten.

Arthur's reviews

  5  
Arthur has 6 reviewsacross 4 different locations, showing 6.
Review Arthur
over 4 years ago
Art is one of the best experiences that I've had in buying a home

Art is one of the best experiences that I've had in buying a home. He helped make the transition smooth and easy. Was patient in securing funding. Recommended a final walkthrough which was unknown as I was a first time home buyer. Gave me the knowledge in different types of property

over 4 years ago
"Communication is extremely important to me, and Art Donnelly exceeded my needs with prompt text mes

"Communication is extremely important to me, and Art Donnelly exceeded my needs with prompt text messages, emails and personal telephone calls. The home I listed with Art was vacant after my father passed, and I lived 30 minutes away with a fairly busy schedule. Art managed the showings, offers, and inspections very well, but special to me was when he went out of his way to visit and check on the house after a nasty storm and made himself available to be there for minor repairs after an inspection. I would highly recommend him based on my very positive experience."

over 4 years ago
"Art Donnelly was professional, patient, knowledgeable, well prepared, and accommodating

Art Donnelly was professional, patient, knowledgeable, well prepared, and accommodating. He was these things and so much more. Selling my dads home after his death was one of the most difficult things I’ve ever had to do. I always felt as if Art knew this. His care of my families needs made the experience that much more tolerable. I would refer him to anyone selling or buying property in the future.

over 4 years ago
I had the most amazing experience working with Art

I had the most amazing experience working with Art. Art helped me find my first home and went above and beyond for me. After I had such a poor experience with a previous realtor and my first home buying experience fell through, Art helped me get my first home! He worked tirelessly in a crazy real estate market to find a beautiful co-op for me. He also got me a great team of a lawyer, home insurance agent and a terrific mortgage broker. He helped calm my nerves and from first look to the closing date, he continued to help me out. He is a wonderful agent! Work work Art and you will completely find your home!

almost 5 years ago
My husband and I had the absolute pleasure of having Art as our realtor - we started house hunting i

My husband and I had the absolute pleasure of having Art as our realtor - we started house hunting in January 2021 - and to say the process was stressful would be an understatement - the market was crazy and it took four months and going through 20-30+ potential houses to finally find our home - despite this, Art was our source of calm in the crazy - he was so patient, encouraging, diligent, knowledgable and he went above and beyond for us - emails and texts never went unanswered - all of our questions, both big and small were answered quickly and in a way we understood (and there were so many questions lol) - he became a friend to us and treated us like we were family, to the point where our kids looked forward to seeing him on weekends at showings - it is very apparent that Art loves what he does, genuinely cares about his clients and is invested in helping home buyers find their homes - we are forever grateful to Art and his network of professionals who are all just as amazing as he is - he recommended a lawyer, mortgage lending agent, inspector and homeowners insurance agent - it is true that good people know good people and Art is good people

Arthur's properties

Arthur hasn't had any property sale activity in the last 12 months

EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent