Andrew's profile

Andrew's reviews

  5  
Andrew has 44 reviewsacross 20 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Andrew's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, friendly, patient, clear communication, dedicated, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
A great deal
5 days ago
A great deal

This is a house I bought for myself personally. It was a great deal and walked into some solid equity with this new construction.

Buyer review
  Flawless experience with Andrew McNeil
5 days ago
Flawless experience with Andrew McNeil

From the start of our search Andrew's knowledge and communication made us comfortable making the purchase of our Florida home. Being out of state he communicated the process throughly and offered suggestions along the way. We highly recommend Andrew for his experience of the market which assisted us immensely in securing our dream home in Florida.

Buyer review
Andrew is awesome and some!!
11 days ago
Andrew is awesome and some!!

We are extremely satisfied of the service that Andrew gave us with the purchase of our new home in Punta Gorda. Moving from Canada with minimum experience and knowledge in US real estate, Andrew had all the answers and guided us smoothly through the process. Any questions he was a phone call await and replied within minutes. Andrew demonstrated caring, kindness and professionalism. If you are looking for a great caring Realtor Andrew is your guy. Thanks again for your great services! Scott & Melissa

Seller review
Tremendous support throughout the entire process
16 days ago
Tremendous support throughout the entire process

Andrew was incredibly professional, knowledgeable and we always felt like he was working with us to find the right home for the right value. We were able to do that, finding a home at market value vs what the owners were asking. Once the offer was submitted, the real work began and Andrew and his team did a great job supporting us throughout the entire process. We were in good hands. I would highly recommend Andrew and the team at Hunt Brothers.

Buyer review
Very detailed and helpful
23 days ago
Very detailed and helpful

Top notch, very professional and helpful! He stays right on top of everything. The entire transaction went smoothly.

Buyer review
Above and beyond for start to finish
about 1 month ago
Above and beyond for start to finish

As a younger first-time homebuyer with no local family support, I did not realize how vital a solid, all-around realtor was to the process. I have nothing but respect and appreciation for the job that Andrew did for me and continues to do. I first met Andrew on a personal level prior to him becoming my realtor, as I was assigned a random agent after inquiring about a home. After a brief conversation with him, I quickly realized my current agent was not the right fit. I was skeptical at first, as any single young female should be, but it was very clear he is passionate and truly wants the best for his clients. He didn’t treat me like just another sale or commission—I was human. He took the time to understand my needs, which made a very stressful process much lighter. As a first-time buyer, I had a lot to learn and thought I knew what I wanted, but I was wrong. Andrew educated me and showed me multiple options and scenarios. When deciding between two similar homes, he had me view both back to back, then revisit the first. I questioned it, but he said, “Just trust me—go back and walk through it again.” He was right. Everything clicked on that second visit—that was the house. During the offer process I was anxious, but Andrew was fully prepared and extremely knowledgeable. He listened to my concerns and even looked into legal issues in the community, which reassured me he had my best interests at heart. We negotiated back and forth with the seller, and ultimately he secured a price below what I expected. I can’t recommend Andrew enough for anyone buying or selling in Southwest Florida.

Buyer review
Excellent communicator
about 1 month ago
Excellent communicator

Working with Andrew McNeil was the best decision we made for our move to Fl from NY. Moving from out of state is incredibly stressful, but Andrew went above and beyond, acting as our eyes and ears on the ground. From detailed video tours to checking on the house when we couldn't be there, Hunts Brothers Reality handled every detail with total professionalism. We felt completely supported every step of the way!! I'm so glad I had you in my corner — and I won't hesitate to send friends or family your way when they're ready to make a move.

Seller review
Great experience!
over 2 years ago
Great experience!

We needed to sell our property and another realtor who does not deal with land purchases gave us Andrew’s information. Extremely professional realtor who kept us updated with potential prospects, our sale, settlement date and any other pertinent information that we may need! Just a great overall experience! Thank you!

Buyer review
From NC to Florida
over 2 years ago
From NC to Florida

We met Andrew when we were looking for a condo in Punta Gorda. He showed us some properties there but we did not find what we were looking for. However, we went back to NC and later saw a condo on line in Cape Coral which had all the features we were looking for so we called Andrew and he looked at the property and sent us pictures along with his honest assessment. We ended up buying the condo. Andrew worked with us over the phone and the internet and met us for the closing. Andrew is very knowledgeable in real estate and very professional. He is also pleasant to work with. We will definitely contact him again if we have a need for a realtor.

Buyer review
An expert in real-estate
over 2 years ago
An expert in real-estate

Andrew helped me identified the land I wanted to build my dream home on. First we found the land, negotiated, found defects, renegotiated, closed on the land. Found the right builder and got everything lined up perfectly. During the building process he checked in on the house and worked with the builder who was difficult to work with. Andrew took pictures and videos during the build time and helped arrange an independent inspector who pointed out several issues, we got those corrected and closed on my beautiful dream home! Thank you Andrew.

Buyer review
Whether you’re buying or selling, Andrew McNeil, is your person!
over 2 years ago
Whether you’re buying or selling, Andrew McNeil, is your person!

Whether you are buying or selling, there would be no other agent that I would recommend. The experience of buying and selling a home can be one of the most stressful endeavors, but working with Andrew has made it an absolute pleasure. Andrew is an expert in his field, and he is personable and timely, and genuinely dedicated to giving you the best experience possible. As a buyer and a seller, this is our third transaction with Andrew, and there would be no one else we would even consider to guide us through. We are super grateful to have Andrew as our agent on either side. We give Andrew our highest recommendation!

Seller review
Would definitely hire him again.
over 2 years ago
Would definitely hire him again.

Andrew McNeil went above and beyond for us. We found him professional, knowledgeable, and dedicated to helping us sell this home. He was very honest with us about the market and our ability to get a fair selling price. Highly recommended.

1 - 12 of 44
© 2026 RateMyAgent