Andrew's profile

Andrew's reviews

  5  
Andrew has 38 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Andrew's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, supportive, friendly, patient, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Very personable and knowledge agent with strong negotiating skills
29 days ago
Very personable and knowledge agent with strong negotiating skills

I was referred to Andrew by a colleague and it was one of the best decisions I made with respect to my home purchase. From our first meeting to signing day, Andrew was there to lend his expertise and be a supportive presence. I was moving from out of town and didn't have much of an idea of where to start or how to turn my homeownership dream into a reality. With Andrew's help, I was able to overcome a setback with an obstinate seller and get into a brand new home without missing a beat. If you're looking for someone who has his finger on the pulse of the Denver Metro market, someone who will keep you motivated when things are challenging, and who will celebrate your success with you, Andrew MacArthur is the agent for you!

Buyer review
Great realtor with expertise in the real estate field and even better human being
about 1 month ago
Great realtor with expertise in the real estate field and even better human being

Andrew is an amazing real estate agent who knows the industry well. He provided the information and insight I needed to make a very informed decision. He has a willing and helpful attitude and made me feel like I was his most important client, although I know he has others. He is a good negotiator and remains calm no matter what is going on and even when other agents are being difficult. This is a wonderful attribute for someone nervous about purchasing real estate. That calm demeanor is effective in getting the deal to the finish line in a professional manner. I felt he always had my back through the process, and now that we are post sale, he is still available to help me in other aspects of the property I purchased. Most importantly, not only is he a great agent, he is an even better human.

Buyer review
Really great agent to work with!
9 months ago
Really great agent to work with!

Andrew is very prompt and helpful with any questions or concerns that you may have! He makes the home buying experience less stressful than it already is to began with. Very friendly and professional.

Buyer review
Best in the business: Trustworthy and Reliable
over 1 year ago
Best in the business: Trustworthy and Reliable

Andrew, is absolutely amazing. Helped my family find their dream home. We met for our initial discussion and quickly reviewed what we were looking for in a home. With his help we spec'd out our vision, identified the price point that worked for us and quickly began the process of getting us into our dream home. Once we found the perfect house he did an excellent job rapidly negotiating and making an offer. He spent the next few days ensuring our family got the best price possible. After we sent over our offer he made sure that we didn't have to think about anything from that point forward. He triangulated all of the contractors, service providers, and loan officers. He ensured that each person he selected to support us in the process was a perfect match. It absolutely was. We will always work with Andrew, and I hope you and you do too.

Seller review
Outstanding Excellent and Well over the TOP
over 1 year ago
Outstanding Excellent and Well over the TOP

Working with Andrew has been the best experience I've ever had with a realtor through nine moves in several different states! Andrew is a breath of fresh air and is very knowledgeable! Since working with Andrew to buy and sell my house in Colorado, he will be the only realtor I work with into the future. Thank you Andrew for the exemplary experience!

Buyer review
Amazing service and it was quick too!
over 1 year ago
Amazing service and it was quick too!

We found a house we wanted after the price dropped on a holiday weekend. Andrew was able to get us a showing and a personal call to a mortgage broker that was able to speak to us on a holiday weekend. Amazing. The process was quick and painless with him having connections to a roofer to quickly answer questions. We closed in 17 days start to finish!

Seller review
If there's a problem, yo he'll solve it
almost 2 years ago
If there's a problem, yo he'll solve it

I had the absolute pleasure of working with Andrew, and I can’t recommend him highly enough! From start to finish, he was a true professional who handled every curveball I threw his way with total grace and expertise. His amazing contacts in the industry, attention to detail, and exceptional problem-solving skills made the entire process fun and stress-free. What really sets Andrew apart from other realtors, is his unwavering dedication and willingness to totally go ABOVE AND BEYOND! No matter how insane or unexpected the situation, he always had a solution ready and never missed a beat. His commitment to my needs and proactive approach ensured that every bump along the road was met with a well-thought-out strategy. If you need an agent who is not only incredibly skilled, but genuinely has YOUR best interest in mind, look no further than Andrew. He turned what could have been a very stressful experience for me into a seamless and fun journey. I’m incredibly and forever grateful for his outstanding service. Thank you for everything Andrew!

Buyer review
Simply Seemless
almost 2 years ago
Simply Seemless

Andrew ensured that everything regarding the purchase was executed on time and kept us on track for a fast closing! Andrew was also very professional and answered all of our questions to ensure we were properly informed all along the purchase process.

Seller review
You Want This Realtor!
about 2 years ago
You Want This Realtor!

Bottom line up front: You want Andrew as your realtor! He knows what he is doing! Andrew was my second realtor who did a few things differently that produced more showings and a quick sale without lowering the price. First off, he has a strong focus on results. He brought in an expert who stages houses and completely changed the interior of my house (I didn't recognise it). His new photographs popped with brightness that pulled in viewers over all the other listings. And most of all, he listened to, and collaborated with, me before really taking charge and coordinating the many activities that needed to be done. I felt very confident during the entire process and was very pleased in getting a good offer I could accept within a month. No doubt, Andrew goes beyond expectations to achieve results - you want this realtor.

Buyer review
Truly Cares
about 2 years ago
Truly Cares

Andrew was a solid recommendation from a friend, and they were absolutely correct. He put COUNTLESS hours and effort into refining exactly what we both wanted…without ANY pressure. He was an outstanding agent and an equally outstanding human, truly caring for our individual needs and wants. I’d easily ask for his assistance again.

Seller review
Andrew is awesome!
over 2 years ago
Andrew is awesome!

My husband and I have worked with several realtors over the years. Andrew leaves them all in the dust. It was so enjoyable working with him that I'm almost sorry the property sold so quickly! Andrew was helpful in many ways. He took care of several small details for us that went above and beyond his realtor responsibilities. He explained the sales process clearly and answered all our questions. He always responded promptly to emails, phone calls and text messages. There were no surprises - except that the property was under contract within 24 hours of going on the market! He had some very creative marketing and staging ideas that obviously paid off. We were impressed by his professionalism, market knowledge and attention to detail. I am still amazed by all he accomplished while making it look so easy. The added bonus is that Andrew has an exceptional sense of humor and a memorable laugh. Thank you Andrew!

1 - 12 of 38
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent