Andrew's profile

Andrew's reviews

  5  
Andrew has 15 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Seller review
Above and Beyond
5 months ago
Above and Beyond

We had a great experience working with Andy. When we hit a bump in the road and fell out of escrow (buyer’s fault not Andy’s lol) he and his wife staged our vacant home and made sure it was beautiful. Home selling can be stressful but it meant the world to us to have sometime trustworthy advocating for and advising us through the process.

Seller review
Great experience buying our new home
10 months ago
Great experience buying our new home

Andy was great to work with. Super friendly, responsive, knowledgeable, professional, and helpful. Our home purchase went very smoothly.

Buyer review
Outstanding Realton
10 months ago
Outstanding Realton

Andy was very effective in helping us navigate the home buying process. This was our first time buying a new construction home. He brought valuable insight into the local market, our specific neighborhood, and the builder’s process and reputation. Andy was consistently responsive, patient with our many questions, and proactive in keeping things moving smoothly. Beyond his expertise, he's personable, professional, and truly a pleasure to work with. We felt supported every step of the way and would highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy a home.

Buyer review
Hardworking and honest.
11 months ago
Hardworking and honest.

Andrew is dedicated and full of integrity. He worked hard for us and got the job done. He was always willing to answer our questions and make sure we were taken care of.

Buyer review
Awesome and helpful.
about 1 year ago
Awesome and helpful.

Our past realtor Janina Beard who was very helpful in getting our home out here recommended Andy Coleman so I could get rental property out here and he was very helpful and when he was not available for a short period his assistant Blair was great as well. I he was very helpful in giving me information on getting a manager and insurance on the new place. All in all I would recommend his service in the future.

Buyer review
Loved our experience!
over 1 year ago
Loved our experience!

Working with Andy was so easy! He was super patient with us as we connected early and then worked to sell our house out of state. Andy was receptive to everything we were looking for in our new home. He was very knowledgeable throughout the entire process, keeping us informed every step of the way. Communication was great, timely responses, and always available, even if on vacation. Although we let him have that time, it was nice to know that he was willing to be available should anything arise. As a family man himself, he was so great and understanding about having the kids and a crazy toddler in tow for all our viewings. I definitely recommend Andy to anyone needing a realtor!!

Buyer review
Beyond What We Could Ask For
over 1 year ago
Beyond What We Could Ask For

Working with Andy was thoroughly enjoyable. He was attentive, knowledgable, flexible, and had our own interests in view. After working with Andy, we felt that we had gained a trusted advisor and true friend. Andy is friendly and generous with his time and resources. Working with Andy made a stressful time in our life an enjoyable experience, which is not easy to accomplish. He is a gifted realtor and overall a great person and was not only a great realtor to work with, but perhaps one of the best people I have worked with in general. I would STRONGLY recommend Andy Coleman to anyone looking to buy a home in Idaho.

Buyer review
Profesional, Timely, Extremely Knowledable and a pleaseure to work with!
over 1 year ago
Profesional, Timely, Extremely Knowledable and a pleaseure to work with!

Andrew was so helpful in providing direction in the recent real estate acquisitions that my wife and I made. He is very knowledgeable of the Meridian market place and surrounding areas. He also provided excellent referrals of other professionals needed for the completion of our transactions. I highly recommend him.

Seller review
Great experience
over 1 year ago
Great experience

Andy assisted us to sell my mom’s house. He answered all of our questions timely and was very helpful in closing the deal.

Buyer review
Awesome Realtor!
almost 2 years ago
Awesome Realtor!

I would definitely hire him again if the occasion should arise.

Seller review
Amazing realtor
almost 2 years ago
Amazing realtor

Andy was recommended to me by my agent in Arizona to sell my home in Boise, Idaho. He was extremely efficient with advice on preparing the property to sell. His recommendations for landscapers, cleaners, staging, etc. were great. I highly recommend him for selling your property

1 - 12 of 15
© 2026 RateMyAgent