Amy Reinholdt

Amy Reinholdt

  •   5   (4 reviews)

About Amy

Amy is a Real Estate Agent at Signature Intl Premeir Propert. They have 4 verified reviews with an average rating of 5 stars. They currently have 13 active property listings and 8 sold property listings over the past 12 months worth $1,783,600.

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 4 reviewsacross 2 different locations, showing 4.
Review Amy
over 3 years ago
HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!

After working in real estate for the past 8 years, I have met many realtors in my life. Regardless of state borders, what I am usually faced with in a Realtor is unprofessionalism, impatience, and money-driven without your rights as a seller/buyer in mind. Meeting Amy was like finally being able to breathe after being suffocated for so long. We live in the Chicagoland area and needed an agent for our deceased mother’s home in Naples. After doing research (and not receiving calls back from other active agents in the area), we luckily found Amy. We also really appreciated her professional marketing photos (so much better than other agents using their iPhones). To make a long story short, after receiving multiple offers, we happily accepted a contract above the asking price. Unfortunately, disaster then struck - there ended up being an error the Title company made back in 2005 when our mother originally closed on the home. What should have been a 3 week period before closing ended up taking over 3 months. Amy was wonderful helping us contacting the Title company, recommending an attorney to hire and working with her contacts in the industry to get this corrected. Then came the hurricane! Amy promptly went to the property for us, took pictures of the landscaping damage and made landscaper recommendations. Throughout the entire process, Amy was always quick to respond, proactive and professional while also keeping our stress levels controlled. We finally closed on the property solely because of Amy's efforts. We sincerely don’t think another agent would have the knowledge and expertise to have helped and stuck with us throughout the entire process. To summarize - we realize our transaction was the worst case scenario. We feel if Amy was able to successfully help with this nightmare situation, we are fully confident that if you’re in the market, hiring Amy is not only the right decision but the best decision you will make.

over 3 years ago
Above and beyond!

Amy went right to bat for us, going way above, and beyond. Working with us from out of state, and knocked any curveballs thrown at us way out of the park. She has the top notch experience, and professionalism that is needed in this crazy market! We can't even say enough. Thanks Amy!

almost 5 years ago
Amy Reinholdt review

Over the past decade, I have traveled to Naples, FL on more than 50 occasions. Each one of those trips included a stop and stay in Windjammer Village where my mother called home for the past 32 years. During that decade I noticed that numerous homes that went up for sale had a common denominator in which they were all being marketed by Amy Reinholdt. My first impression was that the woman had to pretty good at what she did to get all of these listings. Fast forward to February 2021. The resident I mentioned that had resided in Windjammer Village for 32 years passed away and the need for a realtor was now something I needed to research. I interviewed two realtors with one being Amy. The decision on who to choose was rather simple after meeting with her. I was convinced that this woman knew her trade and she knew how to move properties in this community. What I discovered during this time was that Amy was driven to finish what she said she would accomplish on my behalf. The communication between she and I was almost daily reporting results on showings along with discussing alternatives to what we may need to do to sell the house. Her overall professionalism to her craft was amazing. Being that I was almost 6 hours away, she took care of a few things on my behalf that others may have not offered to do. I could not be more appreciative of her efforts. Her knowledge to what had to be accomplished was impressive to say the least. Lastly, along the way I discovered what a truly good person Amy is and I am more than happy to share my experience with her to anyone looking to either buy or sell property. Bruce Scott Orange Park, Fl 714-699-6956

almost 5 years ago
Quality Professional service…

A smooth, satisfactory, easy transaction. Will be pleased to recommend Amy to anyone looking for real estate purchase or sales

Amy's properties

Amy has 13 properties for sale and sold 10 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldApr 23, 2026
$212,500
307/5702 Mayflower Way
Immokalee FL 34142
2
2
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of Florida Nature Realty Service and Signature Intl Premier Propert
SoldMar 31, 2026
$192,500
4/4 Oceans Boulevard
Naples FL 34104
2
2
2
Other
Listing courtesy of Signature Intl Premier Propert and REMAX Hallmark Realty
SoldMar 27, 2026
$250,000
202/1010 Partridge Circle
Naples FL 34104
2
2
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of Signature Intl Premier Propert
SoldFeb 26, 2026
$249,999
2021 Sabal Palm Road
Naples FL 34117
Land
Listing courtesy of Signature Intl Premier Propert
Show all 23 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent