Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 62 reviewsacross 36 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
Honest, concise and reliable

Amy was wonderful to work with. She gave me honest directives to best showcase our home. Her suggestions were spot on. She handled any and all buyer issues and her communication skills were stellar. I never worried about our property as we were out of town owners. Best was no lock box outside our home. She was always present even if another listing agent wanted to view the home

over 3 years ago
She's the best in the business

I was searching for a Realtor who could assist my family in the complicated trust sale. First off, Amy was highly responsive and kept her commitments. She even agreed to join a Zoom call with the family to discuss the market and pricing strategy. Once the home was listed, we had multiple delays and issues surface, but Amy hung in there thoughout the entire process. If you're looking for an experienced professional, look no further than Amy McGrotty.

over 3 years ago
Don't go anywhere else! Amy is dedicated, patient and MAGICAL.

Amy McGrotty's professionalism, passionate pursuit of my seller goals, and knowledge of the real estate climate made this sale possible. Amy and her team of seasoned associates gave me great feeling of confidence and comfort that the deal would be done. I would not rather have anyone else other than Amy in my corner on this or any future real estate transactions. A job well done!

over 3 years ago
Amy McGrotty puts the "Real" in Real Estate.

We would not have been happier. Lighting fast communication, courtesy, and complete market knowledge helped us tremendously. Look no further for an expert and great person to assist you in your real estate transaction. Amy is the best.

over 3 years ago
Smooth and professional transaction

This is my 2nd real estate transaction with Amy in less than 18 months. I've worked with her as a buyer and a seller. I've felt well represented each time, and I appreciate the efficiency and professionalism she brings to each deal.

over 3 years ago
The Best of the Best

Amy McGrotty is exceptional at what she does. She's experienced, knowledgeable, informative, and remains engaged every step of the way from listing to closing. We have purchased and sold several properties in our lifetime. Listing and selling our condo with Amy was our smartest and easiest real estate transaction to date.

about 4 years ago
Just Call Amy

Amy and her team made everything easy for me. She assisted in all aspects of the sale, including best sales price, terms, negotiating, staging, photographs and closing. I am out of state and was not required to come to Florida for anything. Amy is a problem solver and top notch negotiator. Thank you for your tenacity!

about 4 years ago
House Purchase with Amy

Amy did a fantastic job in a tough market. She was very responsive and provided tons of great advice. We highly recommend her services!

about 4 years ago
SHE WAS WONDERFUL.

I`VE DONE BUSINESS WITH HER IN THE PAST. NO PROBLEMS HERE.

about 4 years ago
AMY - THE BEST OF THE BEST, BAR NONE!

Amy brings not just professionalism, experience and friendliness to the table, but she brought a form of confidence that carried me through the closing. There was nothing that can't be done with Amy, nor any questions that were not answered promptly and putting my mind at ease. Expediency with back-ups and everyone she assigned to work with me were good. There was never any pressure and opinions were always honest and befits the situation. I have interviewed other realtor companies (Coldwell Banker, Beaches etc), and I chose Amy. The difference between Amy and the other realtors - Amy wanted what I wanted whereas the other realtors wanted what they wanted. Anyone who has Amy as their realtor WINS! She is the absolute BEST, hands down!

over 4 years ago
Amy Rocks!

Professional, thoughtful, great communicator and highly competent. Highly recommended.

25 - 36 of 62
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent