Amy Caniglia

Amy Caniglia

REALTOR® / Broker / Owner
  •   5   (3 reviews)

About Amy

Amy moved from Upstate New York to Colorado in 1994 with a BS in Marketing and Business Management from SUNY Binghamton. After living in the Vail Valley for 5 years, she made Park County her home. It was here that Amy and her husband Tony raised their two (now young adult!) kids, teaching them how to camp, ski, snowboard, bike, hike, raft, fish and enjoy the mountains as much as they do! Now, their "child" is a Bernese Mountain Dog puppy named Atlas who already loves camping, rafting, hiking, cross country skiing and lots of other mountain activities... as long as it isn't TOO much work or TOO hot out! Amy became a Realtor in 1999 and founded Caniglia Real Estate Group in 2005, the entire time focusing on the greater Alma/Fairplay/Breckenridge area. Today, decades later, Amy is trusted for her expertise, honesty and knowledge in the local real estate market. She is constantly furthering her real estate education and training to best serve her clients, and has earned such distinguished designations such as the GRI (Graduate, REALTOR® Institute), CRS (Certified Residential Specialist), RSPS (Resort and Second Home Property Specialist), RENE (Real Estate Negotiation Expert) and SAS (Summit Area Specialist). Amy is a member of the National Association of REALTORS®, the Colorado Association of REALTORS®, the Summit Association of REALTORS® and the Residential Real Estate Council. She has served 3 terms on the Summit Association of REALTORS® Board of Directors, the same Association that also voted her as REALTOR® of the Year. She was named "Best Real Estate Broker" 2 years in a row and "Best Real Estate Company" by the local newspaper. If you are looking to buy or sell in the Alma, Fairplay, Breckenridge, Frisco, Como, Jefferson, Hartsel and surrounding areas of Colorado, Amy and her team will be your greatest asset. AND, her wide referral network will have you covered if your search is in a part of Colorado that she is too far away from, or even if you are looking in another state! Just ask!

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 3 reviewsacross 3 different locations, showing 3.
Review Amy
over 2 years ago
Super knowledgable about the area, always helpful

Amy is great. Knows the area well, is very responsive, and will help you find whatever property you're looking for. She was extremely helpful throughout the buying process and was able to provide valuable insights on how local transactions typically go. Bonus points for always being down to hike a new property during a showing!

almost 3 years ago
Amy went well above what we expected!

Amy went well above what we expected. Through numerous delays Amy Caniglia babysat us for over a year, while we worked to get the property ready to sell. Amy even enlisted family and friends to help moving items the buyer didn’t want.

over 3 years ago
Found perfect property!

Amy helped us find the perfect property and brought a lot of extra knowledge about the process of building a mountain home. She was great to work with!

Amy's properties

Amy has 30 properties for sale and sold 28 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMay 1, 2026
$642,000
45 Valley of the Sun Dr
Fairplay CO 80440
2
2
5
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Caniglia Real Estate Group Llc and Madison & Company Properties
SoldApr 21, 2026
$95,000
Oahu Rd
Buena Vista CO 81211
Land
Listing courtesy of Caniglia Real Estate Group Llc and Colorado Mountain Realty
For Sale
$498,900
A/108 Sun Rock Drive
Fairplay CO 80440
3
2
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Caniglia Real Estate Group Llc
For Sale
$165,000
313 Porcupine Road
Fairplay CO 80440
10
Land
Listing courtesy of Caniglia Real Estate Group Llc
Show all 58 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent