Amber's profile

Amber's reviews

  5  
Amber has 69 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Buy a house with Amber!
over 3 years ago
Buy a house with Amber!

Amber is the best! The process of finding our house was both fun and fruitful. Whenever we needed something, Amber was responsive and helpful. She knew the area well and always had new ideas when things didn't go how we expected in the tough housing climate. Amber was incredibly patient with us as first time home buyers, and we are forever grateful for her guidance and expertise along the way.

Buyer review
Best Experience Ever
over 3 years ago
Best Experience Ever

Amber was a pleasure to work with on find a home. She takes communication with her clients above and beyond! Very friendly and knowledgeable. If you’re looking to purchase a property look no further and give Amber a call, you won’t be disappointed!

Seller review
Easy and Stress-Free Experience for a First Time Seller
over 3 years ago
Easy and Stress-Free Experience for a First Time Seller

Amber made selling my home a very easy process! She was extremely knowledgable and gave plenty of updates throughout the process. This was my first time selling and her experience and responsiveness was much appreciated throughout the entire process. I will definitely refer family and friends to Amber!

Seller review
Our agent for life!
over 3 years ago
Our agent for life!

Amber's experience and insights were invaluable during our home selling and buying processes. She and RJ provided research and guidance about the market to help decide to sell. They linked us to their network of trusted professional partners to position our home in the best way for our listing. Our sale was not without bumps (through no fault of hers), but she was able to warmly reassure us, then firmly take care of the issues that arose. She made the process even easier to buy our new home with the same dedication and service. Amber is so unimaginably organized and communicative that we might have believed we were her only clients though she juggled many during the busy summer season. We truly felt cared for and that our best interests were her main concern. Amber Herbster is our real estate agent for life!

Seller review
Professional, friendly, honest, great communication
over 3 years ago
Professional, friendly, honest, great communication

We have bought and sold several homes over the last 40 years so we have dealt with many realtors. Amber and RJ were extremely helpful with what we needed to do to prepare our house for selling, being very forthright on pricing, how length of time it would take to sell, gave us great support and advice about which offer would be the best. They helped us through every step right up through closing. Would highly recommend Amber and RJ to anyone selling or buying a home.

Seller review
BEST SELLING EXPERIENCE EVER
over 3 years ago
BEST SELLING EXPERIENCE EVER

This was the second time I was selling my home. The first time with another realtor was very stressful. Needless to say I was anxious about selling my second home. Amber was so friendly putting me to ease about the whole process. She answered all my questions promptly and even helped with putting me in touch with a wonderful woman, Stacy Goodwill who staged my condo and gave me a recommendation on movers, OneOld Man and a Van that got the job done at the best price. Amber actually helped hold my dog during when the photographer was taking photos for the listing! She knew exactly what selling price to list my condo, stragetically put out a teaser "Coming Soon" listing on MLS and the day it was ready I had back to back showings and a contract offer $5000 over selling price by end of day. There were a couple requests from the buyers and she helped me through each request.I really can't say enough about how she takes care of her clients and really made the whole selling experience 180 degrees better than my first experience. I highly recommend Amber Herbster to sell or find your new home. You definitely will not be sorry.

Buyer review
Amber and RJ are awesome!
over 3 years ago
Amber and RJ are awesome!

Amber and RJ were super flexible and always made time for us to see a house we were interested in. They were super supportive in a very frustrating market and made buying a house fun. They supported us in every step of the way and made sure we were crystal clear on the decisions we were making.

Buyer review
Flexible and patient
over 3 years ago
Flexible and patient

Amber and RJ were both great to work with. They were very kind, patient, and flexible. Searching for a home this summer in Dublin was very stressful but they made each showing fun.

Seller review
She's in it for the long haul.
over 3 years ago
She's in it for the long haul.

I "met" Amber on a message board way back in 2003 when we were researching the Columbus area trying to find the right part of town for our family to relocate. Amber was kind, knowledgeable and helpful even though we were planning on renting initially until we learned the lay of the land and would eventually go about purchasing our first home. For the next 12 years, Amber would check in periodically, not pressuring, just checking in to see where we were in the process. We'd been through some rough financial times in the past and weren't confident that we'd even be able to buy a house. Amber helped us see that it really was possible! Not only did she hold our hand through the financial learning process but also guided us to and away from homes that would be good for us. All with NO pressure at any time. She was always available to answer questions, no matter the time of day or day of the week. And if she wasn't able to reply in full at that instant, she'd reply and let us know she'd get back to us. We bought our first house in March of 2017 and loved it. The whole process was MUCH easier and much more possible that we ever thought. We loved our time in the house and Amber was still there whenever we had a question or needed a recommendation for a contractor or service. When we were offered a job out of state this past spring, there was no question who we'd be working with to sell our home. Amber of course! Once again she was patient, guiding us through the whole thing, even putting up with hoops our relocation company made us jump through. My only regret about selling our home is that we moved out of Ohio and out of Amber's area of expertise. No worries, really. Amber is our friend AND our former realtor. I know should we ever have any real estate questions or needs that we'll reach out to her first! You should too!

Seller review
Great experience
over 3 years ago
Great experience

Amber was very professional and was excellent to work with. She helped with issues, was always available. She has a keen eye for structure issues and shared perspectives.

13 - 24 of 69
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent