Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
104 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, friendly, well-prepared, responsive, clear communication, supportive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
An Agent you can truly trust…
over 1 year ago
An Agent you can truly trust…

I first met Justine nine years ago when I was first moving to Lancaster. She was amazing then and I love her still as my friend two rentals and three houses later!! She truly keeps you best interests in the forefront including doing extras when other agents drop the ball! I highly recommend her to everyone looking for an agent.

Justine Dennis McPhee
Buyer review
Justine McPhee was knowledgeable and  guided me through the process
over 1 year ago
Justine McPhee was knowledgeable and guided me through the process

Justine McPhee was knowledgeable and guided me through the process. She advised during the initial showing, looked at details and then communicated with the seller every time I had a question. She followed up on several concerns after the sale and resolved them. Highly recommend her!

Gina M MeierJustine Dennis McPhee
Seller review
Our realtor, Gina Meier with the Meier-McPhee Team, was AWESOME! They give you a concierge-level ser
over 1 year ago
Our realtor, Gina Meier with the Meier-McPhee Team, was AWESOME! They give you a concierge-level ser

Our realtor, Gina Meier with the Meier-McPhee Team, was AWESOME! They give you a concierge-level service. She made calls, helping me decide on a patio door to buy and have installed. Actually she ended up ordering and paying for it to make my life easier. She supplied young men to help with some heavy lifting and moving. The house went live online on a Friday afternoon and we had 33 offers in 3 days. We got together to go over them on the 4th day and by the 5th day we had an agreement to sell. It was absolutely the easiest process with Gina presenting the pros and cons of each offer.I would highly recommend Gina and her team to everyone!

Gina M MeierJustine Dennis McPhee
Buyer review
Couldn't be happier
almost 2 years ago
Couldn't be happier

Justine is an exceptional realtor. This is a difficult process, and I could not imagine doing it without her. She helped us find a home that fit pretty much all our asks when we weren't able to. It was a home that most people would have skipped over but she suggested we take a look despite the photos and man she was right! It was a perfect home for us and we got it for a great price. She is an efficient communicator and very insightful on identifying house issues, negotiation, and providing next steps. Super professional and very nice about answering all of our questions about the process.

Justine Dennis McPhee
Buyer review
Justine is excellent!!
almost 2 years ago
Justine is excellent!!

Justine was knowledgeable and shared many ideas and tips for the house and throughout the process. She advised but wasn’t pushy. She responded quickly to any questions and got answers from the seller, title company and lender quickly. She made the process smooth and hassle- free.

Justine Dennis McPhee
Seller review
Justine is fantastic
about 2 years ago
Justine is fantastic

We have Sold homes before and Justine is by far the best Agent. She was knowledgeable, unbelievably helpful and always responsive to any and all of our questions . Justine made this process enjoyable. We sold our home and have a new friend

Justine Dennis McPhee
Seller review
Justine was a true Partner in our Sale from Start to Closing!
about 2 years ago
Justine was a true Partner in our Sale from Start to Closing!

Justine was a true Partner in our Sale from Start to Closing. Justine is a great listener and understood our expectations and goals before we ultimately gave her our Listing. Justine was responsive to our many questions and always with a smile. Justine had a very good understanding of the potential Buyers and Pricing for our Community. We have worked with realtors in the past but never have found one as good as Justine. We highly recommend Justine.

Justine Dennis McPhee
Seller review
Absolute Super Star Agent
about 2 years ago
Absolute Super Star Agent

Justine was a dream to work with. Her knowledge of the market is unmatched. She came prepared to every meeting with us with facts and figures and most importantly, ideas! Her communication is completely on point, keeping us informed every step of the way

Justine Dennis McPhee
Buyer review
Justine is simply the best
about 2 years ago
Justine is simply the best

Justine was an amazing realtor and made our first home buying experience as painless as possible. She worked with our busy schedule and was able to arrange showings quickly. She was super responsive to our millions of questions and so knowledgeable about the area, the home buying process, and at times anticipated our questions even before we had them! She helped us throughout the negotiation process and was very transparent and honest. I felt comfortable working with Justine throughout the whole process, and cannot recommend her enough. She goes above and beyond for her clients and you will not be disappointed you chose Justine to help you find your dream home!

Justine Dennis McPhee
Buyer review
Justine is very personable and her organization skills are top notch
over 2 years ago
Justine is very personable and her organization skills are top notch

Justine met with us very early in our relocation process. She knows first-hand how stressful an out of state move is and made this side of it easy and fun! She is very personable, and her organization skills are top notch. I highly recommend Justine to anyone looking to buy or sell in the Lancaster area!

Justine Dennis McPhee
25 - 36 of 104
© 2026 RateMyAgent