Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
23 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
6 months ago
We think Evan was amazing!

Evan worked diligently to secure a buyer for our condo. He worked in a very professional manner, advising what we needed to do to prepare our property for sale. He had excellent photos of the property taken for the sale. He worked with us every step of the way and went above and beyond what was necessary to complete our sale.

Evan Marrow

Evan Marrow

  5   (23 reviews)
12 months ago
Sale of family home

Working with Evan from Coldwell Banker and American homes, from the very beginning, he went far beyond what was expected. I started working with Evan years before we began this sale process as we were looking to rent at the time. He spent countless hours with me on the phone trying to help in every way possible. Emails, phone calls, text messages.. his communication didn’t stop. I knew then, when the time came he would be the person to get this done for us. And I was right. We had multiple offers almost right away, and ended up with a bigger offer than ever anticipated. He didn’t just handle the logistics — he handled me and my family with kindness, patience, and understanding during an especially emotional and challenging time. Selling my grandparents home wasn’t just a transaction; it was a major life moment filled with memories, long history, and lots of emotion. And Evan was there every step of the way and not just as a professional, but as a compassionate person and friend. He talked us off many ledges. He connected with us on a personal level, taking time to truly listen, offering support that extended way beyond the capacity of real estate. Whether it was answering every question (no matter how small, and there were many), handling tough situations with grace, or simply checking in to see how I was holding up, Evan showed a level of care and commitment that is incredibly rare. In the process, he became more than my realtor — he became a friend. A true one. The kind of person you stay in touch with long after the paperwork is signed. If you’re looking for someone who will not only go above and beyond, but will do it with heart, integrity, and genuine compassion — you’ve found that person in Evan Marrow.

Evan Marrow

Evan Marrow

  5   (23 reviews)
12 months ago
I dare you to find a better agent...

There aren't enough words to express the way my family and I feel about Evan Marrow. From the moment we started working with Evan, it didn't feel like a typical broker/seller relationship. There was an immediate connection and clear empathy for the task we were about to undertake... selling our family/childhood home. The house had been in our family for more than 60 years. It was bought and paid for by our grandparents’ blood sweat and tears to make sure they had something to leave for their children and grandchildren. So, for us, this was more than just selling a house. It was an emotional experience following the passing of our grandfather in 2021. Evan was there EVERY SINGLE step of the way. He was able to get us multiple offers immediately and the offer we accepted was more than we could have hoped for. Evan went above and beyond on many occasions to help my sister, and I navigate the complexities of selling a home. For that, we will be forever grateful. You will not find a better realtor, partner and friend than you will with Evan. He's a true "mensch"!

Evan Marrow

Evan Marrow

  5   (23 reviews)
about 1 year ago
Evan. The Man. The Myth. The Legend.

Evan, you chaotic legend, I’m still recovering from the emotional shrapnel of that deal, but yeah — what a ride. If buying a home with you isn’t an Olympic sport yet, it damn well should be. You juggled Larry’s daily existential crises, Mitch’s Dollar Store villain arc, and Marci’s spiritual gift for sucking the joy out of every Zoom call with the grace of a caffeinated raccoon in a blazer — and I respect that. Honestly, I’m still not sure if you’re a realtor, a crisis manager, or just a guy who moonlights as all five characters in a Tarantino film. Either way, you made it happen, and you somehow made it fun. Like, laugh-in-the-middle-of-a-gas-leak kind of fun. I’ll drop that review, don’t worry. I just need a few days to find words that are legally acceptable on Zillow. And if I don’t… well, I know damn well you’ll send Larry a thank-you card so passive-aggressive it’ll be framed in his office by Monday. Message received. Stay unhinged, Mike P.S. Still not over the wall unit saga. Mitch owes me therapy.

Evan Marrow

Evan Marrow

  5   (23 reviews)
about 1 year ago
Amazing Realtor

I had a wonderful experience working with Evan as my realtor to find a tenant for my rental property. From the start, he was professional and attentive, taking the time to understand my needs. Evan's marketing strategy was impressive, and he effectively showcased my property to attract potential renters. His knowledge of the local rental market helped in setting the right price, and he communicated regularly throughout the process. Thanks to his diligent screening, I quickly found a reliable tenant. I highly recommend Evan for anyone looking for a skilled realtor to manage their rental properties!

Evan Marrow

Evan Marrow

  5   (23 reviews)
over 1 year ago
Fantastic experience

From start to finish, Evan was professional, knowledgeable and truly dedicated to helping us find the perfect apartment. His communication is outstanding, always clear and patient in answering all of our questions (any time of the day). Evan went above and beyond to make the process smooth and guided us through every step. We found the perfect place in a matter of weeks. Evan truly cares and is very supportive! Highly recommend!

Evan Marrow

Evan Marrow

  5   (23 reviews)
over 1 year ago
Positive experience

Evan was easy to work with, professional and knowledgeable! I would definitely recommend him !

Evan Marrow

Evan Marrow

  5   (23 reviews)
over 1 year ago
Five stars is not enough!

It takes an exceptional person to take the time and truly listen and understand your wants/needs. Evan Marrow exceeded my expectations as a person and a professional. He immediately put together a plan to best market my property and in no time he delivered all that I hoped for and more! He is knowledgeable, driven, reachable and effective! I look forward to continuing our professional relationship. Thank you, Evan.

Evan Marrow

Evan Marrow

  5   (23 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Excellent agent

Evan is an excellent agent. Knowledgeable, professional and responsible . We like him very much!

Evan Marrow

Evan Marrow

  5   (23 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Great agent!!

Evan Marrow is an amazing agent who is knowledgeable, kind, and passionate. He is able to break down all information in a way that is understandable to a new home buyer. He was quick to find us many places to look at and available for all showings. I would definitely recommend Evan!

Evan Marrow

Evan Marrow

  5   (23 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Friendly, Professional and very knowledgeable

Evan went above and beyond every step of the way in our home-purchasing journey. He held a fine line of balancing between being professional and very friendly with great humor. He was always on time and almost every time he picked up our calls. After comparing 3-4 real estate agents, we found Evan's acumen in the real estate market and construction know-how was amazing (very helpful for us). He understands his customers and tries his best to meet their expectations. In every house we visited with Evan, he made a great impression on the listing agents and sometimes on sellers with his magnetic personality. Evan has in-depth knowledge of construction, budgeting, renovation opportunities, home maintenance, and neighborhood details within Nassau County, NY. He walked us through where should pay attention in the house with should and shouldn't lists. He never sugarcoated anything and tried to look at things through our lenses. His recommendations for home inspector and mortgage broker (except the attorney) were a pleasant experience for us. I would highly recommend him to any first-time home buyers.

Evan Marrow

Evan Marrow

  5   (23 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Evan Cares; Delivers; Is Exceptionally Knowledgeable & Always is Reachable

Working with Evan was a wonderful experience! From day 1 he went above and beyond to understand our family's needs/wants. He has a vast knowledge of different home types and home structures (which is a big bonus!) His list of contacts (inspector, mortgage specialists, etc) were helpful & we tapped into them during the process. Evan is a great negotiator and looks for the best possible outcome for his client. He *GENUINELY* (stressing that!) cares and it shows. He is easily reached and has time to talk about different scenarios and strategies. My wife and I were not the easiest clients and came up against challenges, but Evan kept us positive, focused and going forward. We now have our home and are very happy.

Evan Marrow

Evan Marrow

  5   (23 reviews)
1 - 12 of 23
Signature Premier Properties
Contact Signature Premier Properties
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent