REMAX Preferred | Sun Prairie

1500 W Main St , Sun Prairie, WI 53590
  •   5   (6 reviews)

Our sales performance at a glance

See how REMAX Preferred | Sun Prairie has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

1
Reviews
9
Properties for sale
10
Sold properties
$397k
Average sale price
$4m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Meet the team

Get to know the 9 agents at REMAX Preferred | Sun Prairie.

Michael Schuster
Michael Schuster

Broker Associate

  5   (3 reviews)
About Michael

Michael currently has 8 active property listings and 14 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile
About Steven

Steven currently has 7 active property listings and 14 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile
About Tim
Tim Krueger is an accomplished Managing Broker/Owner of RE/MAX Preferred, a successful real estate firm with 12 locations and over 100 agents in south central Wisconsin. Tim is a knowledgeable leader who takes time to address concerns for each of his agents. To stay current with his team's needs, Tim visits each office location, rotating through weekly coffee sessions. With over 19 years of experience, Tim specializes in various property types, including residential single-family homes, condos, multi-family investment properties, and new construction. Leveraging his diverse background, Tim helps his clients understand their options throughout the home buying/selling process. He prioritizes clients' goals, even if that means not buying or selling. Tim's in-depth knowledge and lifelong learning earned him the title of a real estate nerd. Tim became a broker in 2017 and started supporting other agents by teaching classes on best practices. He now serves as a part owner and managing broker of RE/MAX Preferred. Tim also leads the Preferred Homes Team, providing superior service and expertise. He initiated a mentorship program to help new and existing agents develop good career habits and exceptional skills. Tim's dedication to his team's success reflects his passion for the real estate industry.
View Profile
About Daniel
I am a down to Earth professional and I pride myself on customer service. Being an expert in all aspects of my profession is very important to me. Call me, give me your loyalty and I will break my back for you!
View Profile
About Nanci
With nearly three decades of experience in real estate, Nanci has helped hundreds of buyers and sellers successfully navigate the market and has earned a reputation as one of Sauk County’s most trusted and respected real estate professionals. For the past 15 years, Nanci has served as Broker/Owner of RE/MAX Preferred, leading a brokerage of over 100 agents and one of the top-performing RE/MAX offices in the state of Wisconsin. In addition to overseeing the brokerage, she also leads a team of four agents, with a strong focus on serving clients throughout Sauk County. Known for her exceptional customer service, deep market knowledge, and skilled negotiation, Nanci is committed to helping her clients achieve their real estate goals while making the process as smooth and stress-free as possible. Her dedication to integrity, responsiveness, and results has made her a consistent leader in the industry. Beyond real estate, Nanci is deeply committed to her community through both volunteer work and financial support of local organizations. When she’s not working with clients or supporting her agents, she enjoys spending time with her husband, her four daughters and four grandchildren, traveling, boating, renovating homes, and making memories with friends and family.
View Profile

About us

REMAX Preferred | Sun Prairie is a real estate office. They have 6 verified reviews with an average rating of 5 stars. They currently have 9 active property listings and 10 sold property listings over the past 12 months worth $3,974,650.

Our reviews

  5  
6 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 6.
Seller review
Very positive experience.
3 months ago
Very positive experience.

I had an outstanding experience working with Michael Schuster as my realtor. Michael was incredibly hardworking, knowledgeable, and attentive throughout the entire process. He consistently went above and beyond to make sure everything was handled properly and that no detail was overlooked. His expertise and attention to detail really paid off, as he helped us sell our home for above asking price. He was responsive, thorough, and genuinely committed to getting us the best possible outcome while making the entire process as smooth and stress-free as possible. I would highly recommend Michael Schuster to anyone looking for a realtor who truly cares about his clients and is willing to go the extra mile. He did an excellent job, and I couldn't have asked for a better realtor!

Michael Schuster

Michael Schuster

  5   (3 reviews)
Seller review
Very Helpful!!
about 5 years ago
Very Helpful!!

Steve was very helpful in guiding me with the sale of my son's house. Made suggestions, knew contractors that could help with numerous projects. Always followed up with any questions I had and would go out of his way to find answers for me if he didn't know. We were in contact at all times. Even went out of his way to bring in mulch & spread it around!! I would definitely recommend him to anyone trying to sell a property!

Steven Schuster

Steven Schuster

  5   (2 reviews)
Seller review
Quick Land Sale!
about 5 years ago
Quick Land Sale!

Steve got us 10 offers in less than 2 weeks on our farm land! He helped us decipher which was the best offer. We closed in just one month!

Steven Schuster

Steven Schuster

  5   (2 reviews)
Buyer review
Great To Work With
over 6 years ago
Great To Work With

While Michael was not our Buyer's agent, we felt he dealt with us with integrity. He was very responsive to what we felt we needed to make the move. We would recommend him.

Michael Schuster

Michael Schuster

  5   (3 reviews)
Seller review
Tim has been great to work with when selling my...
about 7 years ago
Tim has been great to work with when selling my...

Tim has been great to work with when selling my home. Provides honest good feedback and easy to work with. Very good and fast with communications as well. Highly recommend him!

Tim Krueger

Tim Krueger

  5   (1 review)
Buyer review
Michael has supported me many times. He...
over 7 years ago
Michael has supported me many times. He...

Michael has supported me many times. He negotiated well and found my dream home. I'll forever ask Michael to work with me if I ever need to move on. Thank you Michael.

Michael Schuster

Michael Schuster

  5   (3 reviews)
map

Our properties

REMAX Preferred | Sun Prairie has 9 properties for sale and sold 10 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldNov 9, 2026
$195,000
23/14 Maple Wood Lane
Madison WI 53704
2
2
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of Stark Company, REALTORS and REMAX Preferred | Sun Prairie
SoldOct 30, 2026
$281,500
2984 Main Street
Blue Mounds WI 53517
9
4
Multi-Family
Listing courtesy of True Blue Real Estate and REMAX Preferred | Sun Prairie
SoldOct 30, 2026
$329,500
1241 North Pine Street
Sun Prairie WI 53590
3
2
2
Condo
Listing courtesy of REMAX Preferred | Sun Prairie and EXP Realty, LLC
SoldOct 26, 2026
$259,900
421 S Whiton St
Whitewater WI 53190
4
1
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of REMAX Preferred | Sun Prairie and Shorewest, REALTORS
Show all 19 properties
REMAX Preferred | Sun Prairie
Contact REMAX Preferred | Sun Prairie
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent