Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
28 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
8 months ago
Are you looking for a strong , assertive realtor ?

If you are looking for a strong , assertive agent who will not only find your dream home but also work hard to make it a reality, you want Sarah Olson ! From the start Sarah wasted no time only showing us houses that checked all of our boxes. Sarah had fantastic resources from mortgage rep, to inspectors , all the way down to painter and carpet cleaner. Every contractor was better than the next. Sarah was very knowledgeable and experienced . Excellent at negotiations, timelines and efficiency. Using Sarah and her team we were able to close in less than 30 days ! I would highly recommend Sarah Olson !

The First Coast Collective Team

The First Coast Collective Team

  5   (29 reviews)
about 1 year ago
Most professional and knowledgeable real estate professional ever encountered

I have been involved in 18 real estate transactions over my life and Sarah towers over all the other agents I have dealt with over the years. Her knowledge, unbiased counsel, and diligence have provided clear results, in both good as well as challenging markets. Other individuals looking for a real estate professional would be at best remiss, and at worst, economically disadvantaged by not working with Sarah and her team.

The First Coast Collective Team

The First Coast Collective Team

  5   (29 reviews)
about 1 year ago
Review for Shelby Warner

I had an amazing experience working with Shelby to sell my home. From start to finish, Shelby provided outstanding service, always going above and beyond to ensure a smooth process. One detail that stood out was her commitment to finding answers—if she didn’t immediately know a particular fact, Shelby quickly sought out the right information and relayed back to me without delay. Communication was excellent throughout the entire transaction. Shelby kept me informed every step of the way, promptly answering my questions and providing regular updates. Her professionalism, dedication, and attention to detail made a potentially stressful process feel seamless. I highly recommend Shelby Warner to anyone looking for a knowledgeable and reliable real estate agent. Her hard work and genuine care for her clients truly make a difference!

Shelby Warner

Shelby Warner

  5   (1 review)
over 1 year ago
Excellent

All of the communication with Sarah was very clear and prompt and helpful. I felt very safe with her wealth of experience. All of our negotiations with buyers was clean and reasonable. I highly recommend her for anything related to real estate.

The First Coast Collective Team

The First Coast Collective Team

  5   (29 reviews)
over 1 year ago
Amazing Experience

Cannot recommend Sarah and her team enough. She has made my first-time home buying process a dream. She is always there to answer questions and explain terms and the process as a whole. I knew what to expect next after each conversation with her. She is incredibly knowledgeable in her field and it shows. Nicole is a wonderful person who helped us get ready for closing. She is also extremely knowledgeable and has a great eye for detail. You both are beyond amazing, and I can’t thank you enough!!!

The First Coast Collective Team

The First Coast Collective Team

  5   (29 reviews)
about 2 years ago
Exceptional Service: A Review for the First Coast Collective Team

We recently had the pleasure of working with the First Coast Collective Team for the purchase of our condo, and we couldn't be more impressed with the level of service and professionalism they provided throughout the entire process. From the moment we contacted them, the team exhibited a deep understanding of the local real estate market and listened attentively to our preferences and needs. They were incredibly responsive to our inquiries and always made themselves available to answer any questions we had, which greatly alleviated the stress often associated with purchasing a property. Throughout the search for our perfect condo, the team demonstrated remarkable patience and dedication, tirelessly working to find listings that matched our criteria. Their expertise and guidance were invaluable as they provided insightful advice and expert negotiation skills, ensuring that we secured the best possible deal. Moreover, the team's attention to detail and thoroughness were evident in every aspect of the transaction, from coordinating viewings to facilitating the closing process. They went above and beyond to ensure a smooth and seamless experience for us, making the entire journey enjoyable and stress-free. In conclusion, we are immensely grateful to the First Coast Collective Team for their exceptional service and unwavering commitment to helping us find our dream condo. Their professionalism, expertise, and personalized approach truly set them apart, and we wholeheartedly recommend their services to anyone in search of a reliable and trustworthy real estate team. Thank you, First Coast Collective Team, for making our condo purchase a truly memorable and rewarding experience.

The First Coast Collective Team

The First Coast Collective Team

  5   (29 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Home buying made easy

As a first time home buyer, it could have been scary with all of the unknown but Sarah explained everything. She explained all of the steps and made sure I knew what was coming. She was great at alerting me on properties and thorough on researching the property. When viewing, she would point out what was important. When purchasing my home she made sure that I was treated fairly and getting what was best for me.

The First Coast Collective Team

The First Coast Collective Team

  5   (29 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Sarah Olson is a fighter!

We have nothing but praise for the First Coast Collective team. Their punctuality and professionalism is unparalleled! Every step of the way was expertly explained and done not only in our best interest but the seller’s interest as well. I’m looking forward to purchasing our next property through First Coast Collective!

The First Coast Collective Team

The First Coast Collective Team

  5   (29 reviews)
over 2 years ago
So helpful

Sarah was very helpful and made buying a home while living out of state so easy.

SARAH OLSON

SARAH OLSON

  5   (23 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Wonderful!

From the beginning to the end nothing better! Sarah was a joy to work with and her staff was amazing! I highly recommend this fine group of people to anyone who needs any and all help with real estate. Any question I may have had they were ready and able to not only answer but help when needed. I can't thank them enough for all they have done!

The First Coast Collective Team

The First Coast Collective Team

  5   (29 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Nicole is AMAZING!

We had such a wonderful building experience with Nicole! She helped us so was not as stressful as it was for our neighbors. Her insight and willingness to reach out to the builder on our behalf made the experience seamless!

The First Coast Collective Team

The First Coast Collective Team

  5   (29 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Sarah is the One you need to Call!

5 Stars goes to Sarah. She goes overboard to help you in all your needs. She is always accessible, friendly, knows the market and gets to know you. She finds what you want. You are the most important person to her. She helps in all aspects of the process, so you are not confused. Going over and above is not enough to say what she does. She helped me sell my old house and find a perfect new home for me. Sarah is the family's only realtor!

SARAH OLSON

SARAH OLSON

  5   (23 reviews)
1 - 12 of 28
REMAX Unlimited | Ponte Vedra
Contact REMAX Unlimited | Ponte Vedra
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent