Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
46 reviewsacross 23 different locations, showing 12.
3 months ago
"Expert guidance that goes way beyond the sale"

"I recently worked with Karen to purchase my new condo, and I couldn’t be happier. I was looking for a very specific type of home, and Karen truly understood my vision—she found me the perfect place, better than I could have hoped for. There were many hurdles along the way, but Karen managed and resolved every issue to everyone’s satisfaction. She even helped me navigate the transition from North Jersey to Central Jersey, handling details that were well beyond her job description. She was an incredible source of knowledge, explaining exactly what to expect (like transitioning to an electric-only complex). My grown children helped with the move and were wowed by Karen's expertise and kindness. I’ve been in my new home for two months now, and my son still tells me to get Karen’s input whenever a question pops up. I cannot say enough good things. If you or someone you know needs a realtor, call Karen!"

Karen Scarpa

Karen Scarpa

  5   (5 reviews)
4 months ago
Say "YES" to the "YES TEAM"!!

I have had the pleasure of working with Karen professionally in the past. She is dedicated to her career in Real Estate and loves helping folks navigate their real estate transactions whether buying or selling. Karen and Michelle work well together. I called Karen to get her advice when deciding to sell my mothers-in-law home in Clearbrook. She gave her opinion of value, condition and the current market, not knowing for certain that she would be listing since we were actively selling by owner. She knew our decision was personal and we would need time to navigate the process. Deciding to list with Karen and Michelle was the best decision we made. There were times that I felt the communication was scarce, but having been in the business I know that life gets busy and the emails and texts don't stop, but little did I know that she was working with potential buyers behind the scene navigating a Bonafide offer once she brought it to the table. She took it upon herself to assist with some HOA issues we were having and helped us to resolve a potential unforeseen violation. Prior to listing with Karen many agents were reaching out to us to list the property. When I asked if they had buyer's they all said "No". Karen did not pursue us as For Sale by Owner, we contacted her. She did not try to persuade us to list, she encouraged us to take our time and gave us a realistic price to list. That being said once we listed at the end of August we were closed by the beginning of December. In addition to working with Karen and Michelle, working with attorney Evan Pickus, Esq. made this entire transaction a breeze.

Karen Scarpa

Karen Scarpa

  5   (5 reviews)
4 months ago
Above and Beyond

This was a challenging sale! If not for Karen's knowledge, perseverance and unending patience we would have given up. We are retired Realtors and could not have asked for better representation. Thanks Karen

Karen Scarpa

Karen Scarpa

  5   (5 reviews)
6 months ago
Karen made the process

Karen was more than efficient. She went out of her way to help us through the process and made it as easy for us with whatever situation arose. We would, and we have, recommended her to many of our friends. Karen was not just a realtor, she was a friend.

Karen Scarpa

Karen Scarpa

  5   (5 reviews)
9 months ago
A True Veteran Realtor

My husband and I were referred to Donna Stralkus by another client and we are so fortunate. Donna has an in-depth knowledge of NJ and was able to speak to the specifics of why we would or would not like an area based on our search criteria. This knowledge was indispensable in helping us to narrow down our search areas and ultimately in choosing which houses we should go all in on. Donna's second greatest strength and skill is her deep knowledge of real estate and its inner workings. She was able to guide us through the process, helping to navigate the paperwork, relationships and emotional rollercoaster that is purchasing a home. Last but certainly not least is Donna's natural ability to connect. A clear people person at heart, Donna cared for us by remaining calm and focused and always making herself available. Donna spent countless hours doing research, understanding our wants and taking us around weekend after weekend. She is simply the best and ultimately helped us find our dream home. We are forever grateful we were able to work with her and can now call her a friend!

Donna Stralkus

Donna Stralkus

  5   (2 reviews)
about 2 years ago
As a first time seller I was in no man's land

As a first time seller I was in no man's land. We also had already moved out of state and listed as we left. Donna took care of everything I could have ever hoped for. Had a buyer under contract within days of listing for well over listing price. She took care of all the little things that I couldn't being out of state. The whole process was seamless and stress free. I can't recommend Donna enough. She was awesome.

Donna Stralkus

Donna Stralkus

  5   (2 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Mr. Gareth Farmer- Best Realtor, Ever!

11/3/23 Mr. Farmer was excellent, every step of the way. He was very knowledgeable. Communicated very well and kept us updated. He was extremely efficient and very professional. He was always polite and respectful. We highly recommend Mr Gareth Farmer to anyone. He was excellent and was the best. We thank God for sending him our way and thank you too. Alton and Carrie Douglas.

Gareth Farmer

Gareth Farmer

  5   (4 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Sale of my brother's estate home

Gareth did an outstanding job helping me through the entire sales process. In short, I could not ask more from a real estate professional. He has so much knowledge which he shared, his communications skills are amazing and his level of professionalism is incredible. He truly went above and beyond for me during this difficult time. I would recommend Gareth if you are looking to buy or sell a property.

Gareth Farmer

Gareth Farmer

  5   (4 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Five Star Service

After the passing of my father in 2021, I was left with my family homestead. With both of my parents gone now, I had a hard time putting the house up for sale. I live in PA and the house is in NJ. I couldn't keep this house. I finally caved in and called Gareth Farmer, who my dad had worked with years before, and told him I'm ready to sell. Gareth arrived on time and spoke with a calming and professional demeanor. I felt as if I had known him for years. We took a tour of the house and as we were walking around Gareth was discussing with me how long houses were staying on the market and how much houses in the area were selling for. Gareth pointed out some areas that the inspector might hit us on, but said selling the house would be no problem. The house needed some new smoke detectors and a fire extinguisher. Gareth immediately said he would take care of it. WOW! While going through and signing all the paperwork, I had some teary-eyed moments. Having known my dad, Gareth was visibly touched and shared some calming words. I really don't think I would have gotten through this sale with any other agent. Gareth said he would be listing the house the next day, and, true to his word, the house was listed. Gareth and I were in constant contact with each other. I never had to wait to talk to him. On day three I received three offers! I accepted one of the offers and after the buyer's inspection, I needed an electrician and plumber. Gareth said he know both and could take care of it for me. Again, WOW! The electrical and plumbing issues were taken care of. I can't believe the great lengths that Gareth went through for this sale. The whole time I felt as if I were Gareth's only client. I thought I would be making numerous trips to NJ to take care of matters, but I didn't have to make one! What I thought would be a stressful and difficult process, Gareth made seamless. Gareth's expertise, enthusiasm, motivation and compassion are second to none!

Gareth Farmer

Gareth Farmer

  5   (4 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Very Positive Experience

We wanted to sell our home after living there for 41 years. The home was our biggest asset from our working lives so it was important that we do it right. Gerry was our only choice for handling the sale as he was someone we knew and trusted. We relied on him from the beginning to the end of the sale. He kept us updated throughout and was always available to answer any questions we had. We would highly recommend him to any one looking to buy or sell their home. He was the best for us. William and Monica Crandall

GERALD MCCANN

GERALD MCCANN

  5   (3 reviews)
over 3 years ago
The BEST salesman ever!

Gerry was amazing. I live 5 hours away and he helped us through the whole process, just as if we were next door! Every thing from permits, to cleanout, to moving, to sale, Gerry helped with everything! And, he got us the highest price possible, much more than we ever thought! McCann is the MAN!

GERALD MCCANN

GERALD MCCANN

  5   (3 reviews)
1 - 12 of 46
RE/MAX First Realty | East Brunswick
Contact RE/MAX First Realty | East Brunswick
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent