Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
386 reviewsacross 37 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: hard-working, dedicated, friendly, supportive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Wendy is incredible!
about 3 years ago
Wendy is incredible!

Wendy is truly amazing! I feel like we got super lucky linking up with her. I had been speaking to several realtors but Wendy hit all the right buttons. Interested, helpful, knowledgeable, un biased, kind, and even keeled. Not only did she guide us in our first home purchase, she was incredibly accommodating through the whole process and answered my incessant questions with perfect clarity! She even took some very sweet pictures of me and my husband that we will cherish for the rest of our years. Thank you Wendy! So so so very much!

Wendy Lippert

Wendy Lippert

  4.9   (23 reviews)
Buyer review
Simply the Best!
about 3 years ago
Simply the Best!

I would like to share about my fantastic experience with Real Estate Agent Peggy Rutherford and Polter Real Estate. Peggy was always quick to respond, highly professional, and never afraid to steer me away from a potential bad decision. I truly don’t know what I would have done without her, navigating the extreme conditions of the housing market this past Summer. Ultimately, her wisdom and patience prevailed and I am loving my new home! I am very grateful to Peggy and the good people at Polter Real Estate for a wonderful home buying experience! If you want to buy or sell a home with someone with wisdom and experience, who knows the local communities and housing markets, and who treats you like you're part of her family, then I highly recommend Peggy Rutherford!

PEGGY RUTHERFORD

PEGGY RUTHERFORD

  5   (2 reviews)
Buyer review
Worth every dollar hiring her
about 3 years ago
Worth every dollar hiring her

Alishia is amazing at what she does, she helps with the whole process, every question she had an answer for, she was so helpful, happy and professional what else can you ask for !

Alishia Poorman

Alishia Poorman

  5   (213 reviews)
Seller review
Multitasking super women
about 3 years ago
Multitasking super women

When I say this Agent is a super women I mean it, she works full-time in Real Estate and I would never know, my needs were met immediately, like how she does it blows my mind, super fast, efficient and easy to work with, a permanent smile on her face !!! this Agent is awesome

Alishia Poorman

Alishia Poorman

  5   (213 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent Agent
about 3 years ago
Excellent Agent

5 star agent and Friend !!! I knew I could trust Alishia to do a fabulous job, she didn't disappoint, she is amazing at what she does, if you want the best you hire the best !!!

Alishia Poorman

Alishia Poorman

  5   (213 reviews)
Buyer review
Thank You Alishia !!!!
about 3 years ago
Thank You Alishia !!!!

Super great experience, Alishia is on it, fast, accurate and easy to work with, she goes above and beyond with ease!!! Loved working with her !!!

Alishia Poorman

Alishia Poorman

  5   (213 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent Realtor
about 3 years ago
Excellent Realtor

Alishia was very Pleasant to work with! She has a great personality, and She was ready to show me a house whenever I asked. She was very quick with typing up a contract. I would recommend her 100 times over! (:

Alishia Poorman

Alishia Poorman

  5   (213 reviews)
Buyer review
Amazing agent
about 3 years ago
Amazing agent

We enlisted Alishia to help us put in for a house we wanted to purchase. She went above and beyond every step of the way. Ended up getting it for 59k less than asking price!!!

Alishia Poorman

Alishia Poorman

  5   (213 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent Job
about 3 years ago
Excellent Job

You can tell why she is the number one Realtor in Sandusky County, she really knows her stuff, she is one step ahead and makes sure there are no issues on the way, I had zero stress while working with Alishia, she was fast, accurate and went above and beyond to make sure I was satisfied.

Alishia Poorman

Alishia Poorman

  5   (213 reviews)
Buyer review
Super awesome agent
about 3 years ago
Super awesome agent

stress free, makes things look easy, fun to work with and very down to earth , I couldn't imagine doing a real estate transaction with anyone else. Thanks for all you do Alishia - you are truly one of a kind.

Alishia Poorman

Alishia Poorman

  5   (213 reviews)
Buyer review
Quick, easy, hasselfree
about 3 years ago
Quick, easy, hasselfree

I enlisted Denise to write offer on out of county purchase. She knew where I needed to be price wise and helped me purchase the property for $48k under asking!!!

Denise Workman

Denise Workman

  5   (35 reviews)
Buyer review
Wendy Was Tenacious!!!
about 3 years ago
Wendy Was Tenacious!!!

We drove five days from out of state with the goal of purchasing a home in this area. Wendy was waiting when we arrived ready to get started. Her comment that told me we had connected with the right realtor “I’m here for you”…it didn’t matter what the need, she was ready to accommodate, and she did. On our last day we put in an offer on a new build with Wendy sharing the good news that the seller accepted our offer just before we were to fly out. She was absolutely “tenacious.” I would use and recommend Wendy without hesitation. Thanks Wendy!!!

Wendy Lippert

Wendy Lippert

  4.9   (23 reviews)
181 - 192 of 386
© 2026 RateMyAgent