Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
106 reviewsacross 49 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
My husband and I can not rave about Katelyn enough!
almost 4 years ago
My husband and I can not rave about Katelyn enough!

My husband and I can not rave about Katelyn enough! She was hands down amazing at helping us find our home. She went above and beyond and made the experience delightful, fun, stress free on her end and was always very punctual and responsive! Buying a home can be so stressful, however she made it fun & when any bumps came along in the road she was right there to help solve them.

Katelyn McCarthy

Katelyn McCarthy

  5   (18 reviews)
Buyer review
Allison Smith recently negotiated a difficult purchase of a bank foreclosure for us
almost 4 years ago
Allison Smith recently negotiated a difficult purchase of a bank foreclosure for us

Allison Smith recently negotiated a difficult purchase of a bank foreclosure for us. Allison was quick for all responses, from the initial showing to the delivery of the keys at closing. After many hurdles to purchase the bank owned property Allison showed her dedication to her career by being professional, timely, and sincere. We have been buying properties for over 20 years with a experienced real estate agent that has recently passed away. After this last experience we plan to continue to grow a relationship with our new real estate agent Allison Smith. Allison gets a two thumbs up five star rating from us.

Allison Smith

Allison Smith

  5   (16 reviews)
Buyer review
We couldn't be more happy with our experience with Katelyn!
over 4 years ago
We couldn't be more happy with our experience with Katelyn!

We couldn't be more happy with our experience with Katelyn. We sold our home and bought a new one and while that could have been overwhelming for us, Katelyn made the whole process smooth. She is professional while also being personable which is the perfect mix for an agent. She answered all of our (many) questions and really worked around our schedule. She was also on top of everything and followed up promptly on every step of the process. She made us feel so comfortable throughout the whole experience. I can't recommend Katelyn enough!

Katelyn McCarthy

Katelyn McCarthy

  5   (18 reviews)
Buyer review
Our experience working with Katelyn has been wonderful!
over 4 years ago
Our experience working with Katelyn has been wonderful!

Our experience working with Katelyn has been wonderful. She is personable, professional & responsive. She makes you feel as though you are her only client. No question or concern is too small for her. She will get you every answer that you are looking for. She makes what could be an overwhelming process easy and straightforward. Thank you for all that you have done for our family!

Katelyn McCarthy

Katelyn McCarthy

  5   (18 reviews)
Buyer review
In a year where it was a total Sellers’ market, Katelyn came to our aid!
over 4 years ago
In a year where it was a total Sellers’ market, Katelyn came to our aid!

In a year where it was a total Sellers’ market, Katelyn came to our aid to help us buy our first home after moving to the Syracuse area from out-of-state. She is very personable, knowledgeable, and is quick to respond to emails, texts and phone calls. She totally picked up on mine + my husband’s vibes and knew instantly when a house just wasn’t speaking to us. Katelyn was a delight to work with and made this stressful time a lot more enjoyable by always having a positive attitude and encouraging us to keep going even when we felt defeated. We cannot thank her enough! 10/10 recommend.

Katelyn McCarthy

Katelyn McCarthy

  5   (18 reviews)
Buyer review
Allie was an incredible agent! Her flexibility and attention to detail made the process so easy for
almost 5 years ago
Allie was an incredible agent! Her flexibility and attention to detail made the process so easy for

Allie was an incredible agent! Her flexibility and attention to detail made the process so easy for us. She has excellent knowledge of the local market and really took the time to understand what my wife and I were looking for in our new home. She is very easy to speak with and did a great job making recommendations and advocating for us when it came time to make an offer. Skip the hassle of trying out another agent and choose Allie, you will not be disappointed!

Allison Smith

Allison Smith

  5   (16 reviews)
Buyer review
Katelyn was incredibly quick to respond whenever I had a location that I wanted to tour!
almost 5 years ago
Katelyn was incredibly quick to respond whenever I had a location that I wanted to tour!

Katelyn was incredibly quick to respond whenever I had a location that I wanted to tour. That was the most important thing for me. I never felt like I was missing out on a home because my realtor was slow in getting back to me. She also wasn't afraid to point out any home's drawbacks, which I also appreciated. When you want to buy a home relatively quickly, you tend to see each one through rose-colored glasses, which a realtor could take advantage of. Katelyn made sure I was seeing the aspects of each home that maybe weren't so desirable.

Katelyn McCarthy

Katelyn McCarthy

  5   (18 reviews)
Buyer review
Katelyn is super friendly and easy to work with!
about 5 years ago
Katelyn is super friendly and easy to work with!

Katelyn is super friendly and easy to work with. She helps keep things down to earth and realistic so you know exactly what to expect. I loved working with her and appreciate all the help and advice she gave through every step of the home buying process.

Katelyn McCarthy

Katelyn McCarthy

  5   (18 reviews)
97 - 106 of 106
© 2026 RateMyAgent