Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
28 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 12.
about 6 years ago
Great experience

My husband and I were house hunting while being out of state and Amy helped us find our perfect home. I'm so thankful she worked with us through video chat and she was very honest about things that we couldn't see through video chat. She gave us great advice, even on things we didn't know we had to consider. She referred us to the best people in town with great prices. She went out of her way to get some things done for us that we couldn't. She's just awesome!

Amy Stonesifer

Amy Stonesifer

  5   (28 reviews)
about 6 years ago
The best of the best!

Amy is a true professional who always maintains a high degree of integrity and customer service. If I ever move back to the Pinehurst area the first person I will contact is Amy.

Amy Stonesifer

Amy Stonesifer

  5   (28 reviews)
about 6 years ago
Our Superhero

Amy went above and beyond to make what we felt was the impossible. She worked so hard for my family , calmed me down when things were stressful. We now get to call this amazing place our home ! Amy’s skills , professionalism listening to her clients wants / needs is what makes her such an amazing Broker .

Amy Stonesifer

Amy Stonesifer

  5   (28 reviews)
about 6 years ago

Amy Stonesifer was amazing. She managed the marketing, and the sale of my house which was a difficult situation of a sale and saw it's closing through very professionally. Amy and her staff are efficient, highly professional, and were always available for any questions or concerns. Amy is the best realtor I have ever worked with!!

Amy Stonesifer

Amy Stonesifer

  5   (28 reviews)
about 6 years ago
Extremely easy to work with!

I was recommended to Amy by a family friend. Amy was extremely knowledgeable in the local area and was easy to work with. She was very flexible with her schedule and in showing us homes. She helped guide us through all portions of the search and buying process. Her community connections means she can get you great rates from great services related to inspections, insurance, and lenders. She worked hard to make sure we were getting the best deal possible and that we would be happy with our home.

Amy Stonesifer

Amy Stonesifer

  5   (28 reviews)
about 6 years ago
Great to work with

Amy is very knowledgeable and always gets our product sold . Highly recommend.

Amy Stonesifer

Amy Stonesifer

  5   (28 reviews)
about 6 years ago
Best Agent in Moore County

Amy is a fantastic agent, she helped us buy our first home. We could not be happier working with Amy, she made the entire process less stressful and we actually had fun! She is thorough and detail oriented as well as prompt and super knowledgeable. We never felt pressured and always felt she was looking out for us. We have a unique lifestyle in that we have older children remaining at home and she found the perfect home that gives everyone their own space. Amy really goes above and beyond!

Amy Stonesifer

Amy Stonesifer

  5   (28 reviews)
about 6 years ago
Amy Stonesifer is the ultimate agent!

I chose Amy Stonesifer as the agent to sell my home in Pinehurst because I knew her personally and knew her to be a person of integrity, the ultimate professional, and knew she had knowledge of the Moore County market. When it came time to sell, I no longer lived in the area, and the property had been a rental property. She did the final walk through with my tenants and then began the process of assessing the needs of the property to get it ready for sale. She managed the maintenance of the property during the time it was listed for sale. In my opinion, Amy went above and beyond my expectations. I am truly grateful that I could place my trust in her to be my agent especially since I could not be physically present. Thank you Amy!

Amy Stonesifer

Amy Stonesifer

  5   (28 reviews)
about 6 years ago
Amy - Professional and expert in her business!

Amy has assisted me in both the purchase and the sale of my home in Southern Pines, NC. When purchasing, she absolutely listened to our needs and we found the perfect house in 2 days. Her negotiations with the seller were fantastic, and we were more than satisfied with our purchase. Although I sold again more quickly than anticipated, this only reinforced Amy's expertise in our purchase, and the house sold in 3 days! Priced correctly for the market, it was a smooth transaction and I couldn't be happier. Anyone would be well advised to contact Amy and her team for whatever your needs are. She really listens!

Amy Stonesifer

Amy Stonesifer

  5   (28 reviews)
about 6 years ago
Consistently Outstanding

We can always count on Amy to vigorously market our properties and follow through with a smooth closing transaction.

Amy Stonesifer

Amy Stonesifer

  5   (28 reviews)
about 6 years ago
Excellent Service

Amy helped me sell and locate my new home. Amy told me how to prepare my home to be more appealing to buyers. I was astounded how fast my home sold thanks to her ability to market the home. Amy was very helpful with all the paperwork and contracts that had to be signed and appeared to get them to me immediately. Amy was very knowledgeable about the market and was always able to answer my questions. Amy made this process very easy and I would recommend anyone if they are trying to buy a home or sell one Amy is very professional and skilled to help you do so.

Amy Stonesifer

Amy Stonesifer

  5   (28 reviews)
about 6 years ago
Pink is Perfect!

Amy represents both her buyer and the builder she lists for with professionalism. It is always a pleasure working with Amy because of her knowledge, her pleasant personality and her can-do attitude! I would highly recommend Maison Realty!

Amy Stonesifer

Amy Stonesifer

  5   (28 reviews)
13 - 24 of 28
© 2026 RateMyAgent