Our profile

Our reviews

  4.6  
12 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
100% recommended!!!

Kay was excellent in the process of selling and buying a house. We have worked with her multiple times. She did an amazing job at facilitating the sale of our old house, and the purchase of our new one. She explained the whole process to us and kept us informed at all times, and she also did everything in her power to make everything go smoothly and quickly. She was always available if we had any questions. Kay is very professional and friendly, we will definitely continue working with her in the future and we really recommend her and her services.

Kathryn McGiboney

Kathryn McGiboney

  5   (3 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Fantastic!

Kay was there right by my side while I was going through a complicated probate. She had the house sold quickly! And Kay is always professional but has a way of making you more comfortable about the giant step someone’s taking. She’s simply wonderful about answering all your questions, too!

Kathryn McGiboney

Kathryn McGiboney

  5   (3 reviews)
over 3 years ago
My Experience with Kathryn McGiboney

Kay is very knowledgeable, easy to work with . She handled everything timely. She let me know what I needed to do. Kay is very caring and wants her clients to be happy with their transaction of sell or purchase. I highly recommend her. Kay was always very pleasant and professional.

Kathryn McGiboney

Kathryn McGiboney

  5   (3 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Excellent service

Jamie was there every step of the process, always available to answer any questions that can to my mind. Very professional in every way. Made a new friend.

Jamie Dutton

Jamie Dutton

  2.5   (2 reviews)
about 5 years ago
If you use Justin as your realtor, you will get...

If you use Justin as your realtor, you will get much more than just a great property. Justin not only found us a superb lakefront lot but also sold our house and found us a rental in a town where the rental property is very difficult to come by. He is our connection to the new area where we are moving to. We call him (lovingly:)) our Angies' list. There are not enough stars in Zillow to indicate how much we would recommend Justin!

Justin Peacock

Justin Peacock

  5   (1 review)
over 5 years ago
Working with Kathy has been both easy and...

Working with Kathy has been both easy and enjoyable! Having someone you can trust to have your best interests in mind is very comforting when purchasing a home and Kathy delivers with quick responses and sound advice. Anyone who picks Kathy will be in great hands!

Kathy Daniel

Kathy Daniel

  5   (3 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Kathy is a phenomenal realtor who is extremely...

Kathy is a phenomenal realtor who is extremely kind and knowledgeable. She made the searching and buying process very fun and easy. Kathy has a positive upbeat attitude and always has her clients best interests at heart. She moved at a pace that we were comfortable with and provided relevant comps for us to compare nearby land and house prices. Throughout our time working with her she went above and beyond to simplify the process. She emailed and followed up with lawyers and lenders to ensure we had everything we needed for a smooth close. Kathy was extremely responsive by email, texts and phone and always made time to show us properties at our convenience. It is so evident that she loves her job and strives to make her clients happy. We have moved many times and have worked with numerous realtors and Kathy is by far our favorite!

Kathy Daniel

Kathy Daniel

  5   (3 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
Kathy was a wonderful partner in helping sell...

Kathy was a wonderful partner in helping sell our family’s cabin. She has a good sense of humor, she’s engaged, and she always took action when decisions were reached. My favorite thing she did was communicate consistently and accurately. I have never worked with an agent more focused on the seller’s hopes and needs. She is outstanding.

Kathy Daniel

Kathy Daniel

  5   (3 reviews)
almost 7 years ago
She is great and very professional. She showed...

She is great and very professional. She showed me as many homes as it took to find the right house. She was very responsive to request. She will help you get what you what you need and want. She is willing to help and will negotiation to get you the best deal.

Rhonda Smith

Rhonda Smith

  5   (2 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Rhonda is a true professional. She cares...

Rhonda is a true professional. She cares about her customers and works hard for them. Provides information regarding the market and truthful feedback. Helpful beyond the selling of your home.

Rhonda Smith

Rhonda Smith

  5   (2 reviews)
about 9 years ago
Rhonda is fabulous. We were new to the area and...

Rhonda is fabulous. We were new to the area and she filled us in on everything we needed to know. Once we decided which house to but she negotiated the BEST price. She even helped us find a place to rent until we closed on our house. And she found us a crew to help unload our moving truck. She can do it all. We really enjoyed house hunting with her. I would recommend her anyone.

Rhonda McHan

Rhonda McHan

  5   (1 review)
1 - 12 of 12
Keller Williams Lake Oconee
Contact Keller Williams Lake Oconee
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent