Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

7240 Muirfield Dr Suite 100, Dublin, OH, United States, Ohio
  •   5   (47 reviews)

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

18
Reviews

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Meet the team

Get to know the 3 agents at Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team.

Neil Mathias
Neil Mathias

Owner / Licensed Real Estate Agent / Team Leader

  5   (42 reviews)
About Neil
Meet Neil Mathias, a dynamic real estate professional making waves in the Ohio market. Based in Columbus, Neil has established himself as a trusted agent with a proven track record in property sales. Over the past 20+ years, Neil has successfully sold over 500 homes with $309 million in production, specializing in single-family homes and land—a testament to his versatility and expertise in these property types. Neil's proficiency in swiftly selling properties is unmatched, with an average market time of just four days, ensuring clients receive quick, efficient results. Neil's keen insight into property values is highlighted by his impressive average sales figure of over $625,000, in the last 12 months. With a stellar rating of 5 stars based on client reviews, Neil is committed to delivering exceptional service and personalized attention to each transaction. This dedication to client satisfaction and his deep connection to the Columbus area make him a go-to agent for buyers and sellers seeking optimal outcomes. Neil Mathias is your go-to guide in the vibrant housing market of Ohio, whether you're a first-time homebuyer or looking to invest in real estate. Connect with him to turn your real estate aspirations into reality.
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadge
Colleen Kasulis
Colleen Kasulis

REALTOR®

  5   (4 reviews)
About Colleen
Cutler Real Estate asked Colleen a few questions so you can get to know her better, and here are Colleen's replies. 1. What is your professional/educational background? I have been in sales since I was 15 years old. 2. Why did you choose a career in real estate? A home is one of the most important purchases someone can make. I want to be able to help others find their home and make that experience enjoyable and memorable for them. 3. What area do you live in currently and what do you like about where you live? I am currently living in Powell. I really enjoy my friendly neighbors and the peaceful area. 4. How do you spend your free time? I spend my free time playing my piano, going to Krav Maga and spending time with my family. 5. If you could only keep 5 possessions what would they be? My piano Stuffed doll from my departed grandmother My E-Reader My Nintendo Switch My wedding ring 6. In one word, how do you think your friends/family would describe you? Altruistic
View Profile
Emily Nowak
Emily Nowak

REALTOR®

  5   (1 review)
About Emily
Cutler Real Estate asked Emily a few questions so you can get to know her better, and here are Emily's replies. 1. What is your professional/educational background? I graduated from Miami University in 2006 with a Bachelor of Arts in psychology. I have spent the last 15 years of my career in MedTech selling various medical devices and equipment to hospitals in the Ohio Valley area. I have been very successful earning top accolades almost every year. 2. Why did you choose a career in real estate? I chose Real Estate because I have always been interested in this business. Since we purchased our first house (and before), I have loved to scroll through various Real Estate apps to see what the housing market looks like, what are current style trends, and what areas are most popular. I love to look for houses for my friends and family when they are house hunting. I have realized I have a passion for Real Estate and as I considered a career change, it was obvious this should be my next step. 3. What area do you live in currently and what do you like about where you live? I currently live in Westerville, OH. I absolutely love living here. The small town feel with fast access to everything you would need is ideal. I live in a neighborhood that I would consider a hidden gem. Minutes from Polaris shopping and eating, but a quiet ravine behind our house. We have quick access to bike paths that can take us all over Columbus metropolitan area, but have a small quaint uptown 1.5 miles away. It is truly idyllic. 4. How do you spend your free time? I spend most of my free time outside in the summer. I love to hike, bike, run, and swim with my children. On any day, you will find me on my paddle board in the middle of Hoover Reservoir, most likely trying to make sure my kids don't dump me over :). In the Winter, we spend some time outside, but prefer to be snuggled up by the fire. We play games, watch movies or television, and read books. 5. If you could only keep 5 possessions what would they be? This is a difficult question! I believe the 5 possessions I would keep are: My Bible My wedding ring A pair of sunglasses A coffee cup My running shoes 6. In one word, how do you think your friends/family would describe you? Exuberant
View Profile

About us

The Mathias Team w/Cutler Real Estate is a collaboration of local realtors working together towards

Our reviews

  5  
46 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 6.
Buyer review
The best of the best!
7 days ago
The best of the best!

I cannot say enough positive things about Neil and his team. Neil has an incredible combination of knowledge of the real estate market, home construction, and the Columbus area that has given us confidence as home buyers. The attention and connection Neil provides through the buying process makes the whole experience so much less stressful than it could be. He is honest, experienced, intuitive, observant, and efficient. He truly makes the buying experience a team effort, guiding us through to find the right fit for our family.

Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

  5   (14 reviews)
Buyer review
Exceptionally knowledgeable. Great communicator. Amazing advocate for clients.
14 days ago
Exceptionally knowledgeable. Great communicator. Amazing advocate for clients.

Neil knows the Columbus market better than anyone I’ve met. He has an amazing understanding of home building, renovating, and repairs which allows you to walk into a home and imagine what it can become. Neil is the only realtor we will work with!

Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

  5   (14 reviews)
Buyer review
Knowledgeable agent with a personal touch
16 days ago
Knowledgeable agent with a personal touch

Emily knows her stuff! She was able to communicate efficiently and quickly on our entire buying and selling process. Her expertise made our experience feel seamless. We highly recommend Emily!

Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

  5   (14 reviews)
Buyer review
Extremely responsive and communicative
18 days ago
Extremely responsive and communicative

Neil is highly knowledgeable in his area which gets reflected in the very first conversation one has with him. He is very approachable and you can ask him any questions without any inhibition - he makes you feel that comfortable. Whenever my husband and I were ready with our shortlisted properties, Neil was always available to accompany us for tours and help us understand the pros as well as the cons associated with a particular property, which really helped us narrow down our decision. With Neil, everything is seamless - from touring through closing. We will continue to recommend Neil for our friends and family members who are looking to buy and sell properties.

Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

  5   (14 reviews)
Buyer review
As first-time buyers, Neil guided us every step and found us the perfect home.
29 days ago
As first-time buyers, Neil guided us every step and found us the perfect home.

We had a great experience working with Neil! As first-time homeowners, he guided us through every step and made the process feel easy and stress-free. He truly had our best interests in mind and helped us find an amazing first home. We’re so grateful and highly recommend him!

Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team

  5   (14 reviews)
Show all 46 reviews
map

Our properties

Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team hasn't had any property sale activity in the last 12 months

Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team
Contact Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent