Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
15 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Another 5 Star Transaction with Neil Mathias
14 days ago
Another 5 Star Transaction with Neil Mathias

Was extremely helpful in making the right decision with my home purchase. I had been looking in a particular area for a few years without any luck. Neil made sure that we found the right home for me. His knowledge of the market is unmatched, and he has all the right insights that any buyer or seller would be looking for. His attention to detail, his responsiveness and his insight is something that is seemingly more and more rare in today's market. You are in the best hands with the Mathias Team! I cannot recommend the team enough!

Neil Mathias
Buyer review
The best of the best!
about 2 months ago
The best of the best!

I cannot say enough positive things about Neil and his team. Neil has an incredible combination of knowledge of the real estate market, home construction, and the Columbus area that has given us confidence as home buyers. The attention and connection Neil provides through the buying process makes the whole experience so much less stressful than it could be. He is honest, experienced, intuitive, observant, and efficient. He truly makes the buying experience a team effort, guiding us through to find the right fit for our family.

Neil Mathias
Buyer review
Knowledgeable agent with a personal touch
2 months ago
Knowledgeable agent with a personal touch

Emily knows her stuff! She was able to communicate efficiently and quickly on our entire buying and selling process. Her expertise made our experience feel seamless. We highly recommend Emily!

Emily Nowak
Buyer review
Extremely responsive and communicative
2 months ago
Extremely responsive and communicative

Neil is highly knowledgeable in his area which gets reflected in the very first conversation one has with him. He is very approachable and you can ask him any questions without any inhibition - he makes you feel that comfortable. Whenever my husband and I were ready with our shortlisted properties, Neil was always available to accompany us for tours and help us understand the pros as well as the cons associated with a particular property, which really helped us narrow down our decision. With Neil, everything is seamless - from touring through closing. We will continue to recommend Neil for our friends and family members who are looking to buy and sell properties.

Neil Mathias
Buyer review
Fantastic and great communication
2 months ago
Fantastic and great communication

Jackson from day one was making sure my home was everything I asked for he checked in often always answered when I called for questions he is friendly and helped me find my home and was with me for every step

Jackson Deitrick
Buyer review
As first-time buyers, Neil guided us every step and found us the perfect home.
2 months ago
As first-time buyers, Neil guided us every step and found us the perfect home.

We had a great experience working with Neil! As first-time homeowners, he guided us through every step and made the process feel easy and stress-free. He truly had our best interests in mind and helped us find an amazing first home. We’re so grateful and highly recommend him!

Neil Mathias
Buyer review
found me my forever home
4 months ago
found me my forever home

listened to what i was looking for, found me my forever house before it was listed and effectively managed a difficult situation with the seller. neil was professional, communicates well and has been a great resource throughout the process

Neil Mathias
Buyer review
Great Experience
5 months ago
Great Experience

Colleen helped us to find the home of our dreams! She listened, understood our needs, and offered help in any way she could. When the home we purchased went on the market, she knew that we had found a good option and helped us to quickly see the property and place an appealing offer. She checked in often throughout the process, which kept stress minimal. Colleen is incredibly knowledgeable, helpful, and all around great person.

Colleen Kasulis
Seller review
Professional and tailored service
6 months ago
Professional and tailored service

In every respect our experience with our realtor was 100% what we needed. We haven’t been on the realty market for over three decades and we had a lot of questions and anxieties. At every point our concerns were answered promptly and professionally. It could not have gone more smoothly.

Neil MathiasColleen Kasulis
1 - 12 of 15
Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team
Contact Cutler Real Estate | The Mathias Team
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent