Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
136 reviewsacross 45 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: strategic, patient, friendly, supportive, clear communication, local expert, responsive.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Kind, quick communication, heart of a teacher
7 months ago
Kind, quick communication, heart of a teacher

Lindsey helped me and my husband buy our first home. She explained everything each step of the way in a way that made us feel comfortable and empowered through the process. She responds so quickly! She is one of the sweetest people I’ve ever met. I hope to work with her in the future!!

Lindsey Riley

Lindsey Riley

  5   (61 reviews)
Buyer review
Wonderful experience, great knowledge!
7 months ago
Wonderful experience, great knowledge!

Lindsey was very responsive to all our questions as a first time home buyer. She showed up to everything and made sure we understood what we were doing every step of the way.

Lindsey Riley

Lindsey Riley

  5   (61 reviews)
Seller review
Fantastic agent!
7 months ago
Fantastic agent!

We had an outstanding experience working with Sebastian to sell our home! From the very beginning, he impressed us with his professionalism, clear communication, and deep knowledge of the market. He guided us through every step of the process with confidence and care, making what could have been stressful feel effortless. Sebastian’s pricing strategy, attention to detail, and marketing approach were spot-on—our home received incredible interest and sold faster (and for more) than we expected. He kept us informed at every stage and went above and beyond to make sure everything went smoothly, from staging advice to closing day. If you’re looking for someone who is not only skilled but genuinely invested in your success, Sebastian is the realtor you want on your team. We couldn’t be happier with the results and highly recommend him to anyone looking to sell their home!

Sebastian Neikirk

Sebastian Neikirk

  5   (14 reviews)
Seller review
Relaxed, professional, and dedicated!
7 months ago
Relaxed, professional, and dedicated!

Sebastian is exactly who we needed as our realtor. He isn’t pushy, showy, or your stereotypical “realtor”. He’s genuine and works hard to provide the best for his clients. He helped us sell our starter home, helped negotiate the deal on our dream home, and he has been patient and kind with my elderly father when he considered buying a home a few months ago. Sebastian is flexible, understanding, and the type of guy you want in your corner. We love Seb and will continue to use him and recommend him to all our friends!

Sebastian Neikirk

Sebastian Neikirk

  5   (14 reviews)
Buyer review
Made My First Home Purchase a Joy, Not a Stress
7 months ago
Made My First Home Purchase a Joy, Not a Stress

Working with Lindsey was an incredible experience from start to finish. She is truly a wealth of knowledge, not only about real estate itself but about every step of the process, from scheduling showings and setting up utilities to navigating closing details with the title company and more. Lindsey goes above and beyond for her clients in every possible way. She is attentive, thorough, and genuinely invested in helping you find the right home. During showings, she took the time to evaluate each property with my needs and wants in mind, often noticing details I would have missed. It’s clear that she always has her clients’ best interests at heart. Buying my first home was exciting, but also scary, intimidating and at times overwhelming. Lindsey made it all feel manageable. She ensured I understood every step, answered my many questions (even late at night!), and never made me feel rushed or uncertain. I truly cannot say enough good things about Lindsey Riley. She’s an exceptional realtor and an even better person. If you’re looking for someone who is professional, deeply knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in helping you find the perfect home — Lindsey is the one.

Lindsey Riley

Lindsey Riley

  5   (61 reviews)
Buyer review
Amazing and dedicated!
7 months ago
Amazing and dedicated!

Krista did many, many things that a normal agent would not even think about doing. She should get paid much more than her small % age. I will compensate her myself. I would rate her #1!

Krista Combs

Krista Combs

  5   (47 reviews)
Buyer review
Helpful and knowledgeable
8 months ago
Helpful and knowledgeable

Krista was always prompt in responding to requests, showings, and questions. She showed knowledge of the market and expertise about pros and cons of each property. She also attended the closing to answer questions. Highly recommended.

Krista Combs

Krista Combs

  5   (47 reviews)
Buyer review
Great experience.
8 months ago
Great experience.

Couldn’t have asked for a better agent. Krista was very knowledgeable. She gave great advice and answered all my questions. Would definitely use her again.

Krista Combs

Krista Combs

  5   (47 reviews)
Seller review
Simply the best
8 months ago
Simply the best

Lindsey is the best in the business! Selling this home was a challenge from start to finish, and Lindsey made the process so much better by constantly communicating and working hard on my behalf. I would highly recommend Lindsey if you're looking to buy or sell, you will be happy you did!

Lindsey Riley

Lindsey Riley

  5   (61 reviews)
Buyer review
Hardworking, Knowledgeable, and Truly Caring
8 months ago
Hardworking, Knowledgeable, and Truly Caring

We are so grateful to have worked with Lindsey Riley on buying our very first home! As first-time home buyers, we had a lot of questions and uncertainty, but she guided us through every step of the process with so much patience and knowledge. She went above and beyond, often working late into the night to make sure everything was taken care of and that we had the best chance at getting the home we wanted. She never pressured us, but instead, offered thoughtful suggestions and advice that truly helped us make the best decision for our family. Her dedication, responsiveness, and expertise made such a difference, and we couldn't imagine going through this milestone without her. We highly recommend Lindsey Riley to anyone looking for a realtor who genuinely cares and works tirelessly for her clients!

Lindsey Riley

Lindsey Riley

  5   (61 reviews)
Buyer review
A great help in finding our property
8 months ago
A great help in finding our property

Krista was patient with us and showed many properties to us until we found the property that met our unique needs. Once the property was found she provided valuable advice on how to proceed and what to expect. We had used Krista before and knew that she is great to work with and would furnish all of the assistance that we would need.

Krista Combs

Krista Combs

  5   (47 reviews)
Seller review
A wonderful experience!
9 months ago
A wonderful experience!

Lindsey was so kind, knowledgeable and patient- she answered our many questions throughout the buying and selling process. Her communication was superb, we received frequent updates, and she went above and beyond to make sure we understood the entire process.

Lindsey Riley

Lindsey Riley

  5   (61 reviews)
25 - 36 of 136
Cutler Real Estate | Stow/Cuyahoga Falls
Contact Cutler Real Estate | Stow/Cuyahoga Falls
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent