Affordable Real Estate Company

5320 E Main St Suite 400 Columbus, OH 43213
  •   5   (54 reviews)

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Affordable Real Estate Company has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

12
Reviews
12
Properties for sale
36
Sold properties
$228k
Average sale price
$8.2m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Meet the team

Get to know the 7 agents at Affordable Real Estate Company.

Vanessa Sutton
Vanessa Sutton

Principal Broker

  5   (23 reviews)
About Vanessa
I am a skilled decision-maker, negotiator, and communicator with a successful 41-year career in real estate sales and marketing. A truly dedicated professional with a drive and passion for the real estate business who never gives up until the job is done. A strategic thinker who analyzes information and evaluates the results needed to get the best solution and solve problems. Strong communicator with excellent time management skills, self-motivation, and compassion. Columbus REALTIST Association - 25 Million Dollar Pinnacle Performance Award - 2019 Columbus REALTIST Association - President's Choice Stellar Award - 2021 Columbus REALTORS - President's Excellence Award - 2021 TCT - Circle of Excellence Award - 2021
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadge
Gail Tate-Johnson
Gail Tate-Johnson

Sales Agent

  5   (15 reviews)
About Gail
I'm a Buckeye, through & through. Born in Columbus, attending OSU and ODU, with a BA in Communications and a minor in Education. I am a mother, gigi, daughter, sister, mentor, foster parent & BFF...I cherish these relationships. I've been a real estate professional for nearly 25 years and have acquired many awards and distinctions. One of my greatest joys is representing clients as they begin their wealth-building journey...starting with real estate. I am committed to using my knowledge, experience, energy & attention in assisting my clients on their real estate adventure. Whether purchasing a newly built home, an existing home, selling a current property, or investing, contact me, and let's get started, TODAY! "The GEM Finder!" Services Provided: New Construction HUD Homes VA Acquired Homes Short Sales Commercial & Investment Properties Education & Experience: BA, Mass Communications - Ohio Dominican University Certified Diversity Real Estate Professional USACares Military Housing Specialist CBR-Equal Opportunity Committee Mentor/Trainer Professional Affiliations & Awards: Columbus REALTIST Association, President 2014 - 2015 Ohio REALTIST Association - REALTIST of the Year - 2015 National Association of Real Estate Broker (NAREB) Columbus Board of Realtors - Million Dollar Club Ohio Association of Realtors - President's Club Member
View Profile
Pauline Buck
Pauline Buck

Sales Manager

  5   (9 reviews)
About Pauline
Welcome to the premier resource for all real estate information and transaction in the area. Affordable Real Estate has been serving greater Columbus area and surrounding communities since 1995. I specialize in representing my clients in all residential transactions to include, but not limited to, the purchase and sale of single-family properties, multi-family properties, investment property and commercial opportunities within Franklin, Fairfield and licking counties. I enjoy working with first-time buyers and the next home buyers. However, as your realtor for life, I provide information that will help you through any situations the affect your home. My Brokerage experiences and high talented, professional agents equips me to handle any challenge that may arise.
View Profile
Mamadou Sy
Mamadou Sy

Sales Agent

  5   (7 reviews)
About Mamadou

Mamadou currently has 8 active property listings and 8 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile
Ealnor Grey
Ealnor Grey

Sales Agent

About Ealnor
[CU]
View Profile
Kathy Ervin
Kathy Ervin

Sales Agent

About Kathy
Kathy is a seasoned real estate professional with 13 years of expertise in Real Estate Owned (REO) & Residential properties. She is passionate about creating generational wealth through homeownership, growing her real estate career, and helping her clients make their dreams come true. Kathy also enjoys traveling the world and spending time with her family and friends.
View Profile

About us

History We have been serving the greater COLUMBUS area and surrounding communities since 1995. Agents Our firm consists of high caliber professionals with diverse backgrounds. They are ALL committed to the Business of Real Estate. Office and Staff Our office is fully equipped with a high tech equipment and communication system. We have instant access to all Multiple Listing Services, Public Record Searches, and other tools and services that our agents need in order to better serve you. We also have a administrative assistant to accommodate your needs. She helps coordinate meetings, set schedules, answer your calls when your agent is not available, and is your personal courier to ensure the timely delivery of all your documents.

Our reviews

  5  
54 reviewsacross 22 different locations, showing 6.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, clear communication, responsive, patient, reliable, supportive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Experience matters
4 days ago
Experience matters

Vanessa's experience made a difference in winning the bid on this property. Also once over, Vanessa pointed out errors in the listing agents paperwork. Thank you Vanessa!

Vanessa Sutton

Vanessa Sutton

  5   (23 reviews)
Seller review
Very honest, hard working and very professional
6 days ago
Very honest, hard working and very professional

Everything I needed to know about the market, and during negotiations Ms Tate explained thoroughly and walked me through every step making everything very comfortable and smooth during the process.

Gail Tate-Johnson

Gail Tate-Johnson

  5   (15 reviews)
Buyer review
Absolutely Amazing
3 months ago
Absolutely Amazing

Without her, I don’t know if the purchase would have gone through. When the loan officer dragged their feet, this sweat hearted woman became a bulldog and got stuff done! She’s amazing! I can’t thank her enough for everything she did for me.

Vanessa Sutton

Vanessa Sutton

  5   (23 reviews)
Seller review
Professional, efficient, very good marketing!
4 months ago
Professional, efficient, very good marketing!

Vanessa's years of experience showed in the listing and marketing of our property. Priced accurately per open house visitors, and sold quickly. In conversations during price negotiations, her insight was extremely helpful and sold at full list price. We are looking forward to working with Vanessa again. Thank you!

Vanessa Sutton

Vanessa Sutton

  5   (23 reviews)
Buyer review
feedback for pauline
9 months ago
feedback for pauline

loved working with pauline always there for me fighting on my behalf asking questions i didn’t think of highly recommended

Pauline Buck

Pauline Buck

  5   (9 reviews)
Show all 54 reviews
map

Our properties

Affordable Real Estate Company has 12 properties for sale and sold 36 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$145,000
1674 Geraldine Avenue
Columbus OH 43219
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Affordable Real Estate Company
SoldMay 22, 2026
$108,750
961 Geers Avenue
Columbus OH 43206
2
1
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Capital Partners and Affordable Real Estate Company
SoldMay 15, 2026
$260,000
1363 Coburg Road
Columbus OH 43227
4
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Greater Cols and Affordable Real Estate Company
For Sale
$415,000
5565 Effy Ln
Columbus OH 43110
4
4
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Affordable Real Estate Company
Show all 48 properties
© 2026 RateMyAgent