9231 E Poynter Dr

Morgantown IN 46160

2849 sq. ft.

76186 sq. ft.

Single-Family

Last sold for $665,000

Maria Ridenour, last sold this property on 11 December 2025 after 180 days on market.

Overview

Escape the daily grind & embrace the simple life on the 1.75ac lot overlooking the 16ac lake found in St Johns Commons. Lake life at it's finest! A rural community w/luxury homes that allows you full access to enjoy the private lake whether it is fishing, swimming, boating or relaxing. Tucked at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, this 3BR/3Full BA Craftsman Style home spans just under 2,850 Sq. Ft. of finished living space. From the moment you step onto the charming covered front porch, you're greeted with attention to detail at every corner. The open-concept layout features a split floor plan for added privacy, while the spacious kitchen impresses with granite countertops, walk-in pantry, breakfast bar, and an island-ideal for impromptu baking marathons or quiet morning coffees. The 36/42-inch cabinets gleam with crown molding (also found throughout home), perfectly accented by a chimney-style vent hood, pot filler, tiled backsplash & SS appliances. The stone surround wood burning fireplace w/insert & blower brings warmth & ambiance to the 18x26 main living area. The 2nd level 15x29 bonus room boasts a full bath which opens the door to endless uses-think in-law suite, media room, or possibly your long-awaited hobby haven. Retreat to the 14x21 primary BR that boasts a spacious walk-in closet, tray ceiling, dual sinks, garden tub, separate tiled shower, and a private entrance-perfect for sneaking out to enjoy the backyard view on the 11x13 covered patio, admire the peaceful water views with your morning tea or unwinding beneath the stars in the hot tub that is conveniently situated on the large trek deck (36x39) with cable railing. Besides the spacious 3 car attached garage (28x33) you will find a 16x24 detached garage w/concrete floor, 220 volt electrical & a ceiling fan outlet. Spacious laundry room with cabinetry, ample storage throughout, & an outdoor backdrop perfect for entertaining or just to simply enjoy the view and nature - you have found your new home!

Features

3 bedrooms

3 bathrooms

3 carspaces

3 garage spaces

2849 sq. ft. floor area

76186 sq. ft. lot size

Single-Family

Estimated Value

Based on this property and similar 3 bedroom single-family properties sold in Morgantown over the last 12 months, the estimated median property value of 9231 E Poynter Dr is $345k.

Median value

$345k

Estimated value range

$30k - $2.1m

Median days on market

Estimated value trend

10%

increase over the last 12 months

Average days on market is based on recent, comparable sales in Morgantown. It is only an indication of the time a property is actively listed and should not be relied upon as an accurate representation of how soon a property will be sold.

Property history for 9231 E Poynter Dr

2025

Sold

$665,000

11 Dec 2025 by Maria Ridenour, of Ridenour Real Estate Services,

2019

Sold

$207,692

02 Dec 2019

2019

Sold

$47,000

05 Jun 2019 by Carrie Vavul, of Carpenter Realtors - Trafalgar

Happy sellers in Morgantown

We have insufficient information to provide an overview of customer satisfaction for Morgantown. Viewing the agent profiles, reviews and sales for Morgantown can provide insights for this location.