538 Olde Mill Dr

Off Market

538 Olde Mill Dr

Westerville OH 43082

4260 sq. ft.

13503.6 sq. ft.

Single-Family

Last sold for $555,000

Craig Buehler, last sold this property on 02 July 2025 after 33 days on market.

Overview

WELCOME TO YOUR DREAM HOME IN THE HIGHLY SOUGHT-AFTER OLDE MILL COMMUNITY! This stunning custom-built 5 bedroom, 3.5-bath home is loaded with upgrades, timeless charm, and thoughtful design throughout, perfectly situated on an oversized 1/3-acre lot offering space, privacy, and beautiful mature landscaping. Step inside and you'll be welcomed by a spacious layout that includes a large entryway, formal dining room w/ tray ceiling, private den w/ built-in bookshelves, & spacious great room w/ vaulted ceilings, skylights, wainscoting & cozy gas log fireplace w/ white brick hearth. The chef's kitchen boasts SS appliances, granite counters, gas range & bayed breakfast nook filled w/ natural light. A formal living room adds extra space for entertaining or relaxing. Hardwood floors flow through much of the main level, adding warmth & elegance. Upstairs features a luxurious owner's suite w/ soaring ceilings, spa-like bath w/ dual vanities, soaking/Jacuzzi tub, separate shower, & massive walk-in closet w/ dormer window. 3 additional generously sized bedrooms provide plenty of space for everyone. The professionally finished lower level w/ 1,200 SF is a game-changer including a potential 5th BR, full bath, kitchenette, cozy living area w/ gas fireplace & abundant storage?perfect for guests, in-laws, or private retreat. Tons of storage throughout incl 2 entry closets, large upstairs hallway closet, generous LL storage space and cabinets/shelving in the garage. Outside, enjoy peaceful outdoor living with a covered deck, built-in firepit, and picturesque yard framed by mature trees. The side-load garage enhances the curb appeal, Prime location within walking distance to Westerville schools & parks. Minutes to Hoover Reservoir, Uptown Westerville, Polaris, Easton, dining, shopping & freeway access. This home checks every box for location, luxury & space!

Features

5 bedrooms

4 bathrooms

2 carspaces

2 garage spaces

4260 sq. ft. floor area

13503.6 sq. ft. lot size

Single-Family

Estimated Value

Based on this property and similar 5 bedroom single-family properties sold in Westerville over the last 12 months, the estimated median property value of 538 Olde Mill Dr is $810k.

Median value

$810k

Estimated value range

$451k - $2.9m

Median days on market

Estimated value trend

16%

increase over the last 12 months

Average days on market is based on recent, comparable sales in Westerville. It is only an indication of the time a property is actively listed and should not be relied upon as an accurate representation of how soon a property will be sold.

Property history for 538 Olde Mill Dr

2025

Sold

$555,000

02 Jul 2025 by Craig Buehler, of Coldwell Banker Realty

2017

Sold

$350,000

07 Aug 2017 by Ranee Brown, of BerkshireHathawayPlatRltyGroup

Happy sellers in Westerville

89%

89% of sellers in Westerville reported that their sale price either exceeded or met their price expectations.

Westerville stands out for consistently delivering exceptional satisfaction and strong market results for homeowners.

This is based on voluntary sentiment collected from 7 reviews in Westerville over the last 12 months.

Local market activity for 5 bedroom single-family properties in Westerville

In the last 12 months, 36 five-bedroom single-family properties similar to 538 Olde Mill Dr, have been sold.

This represents a 42% decrease in five-bedroom single-family properties sales when compared to the previous 12 months.

Sold

For Sale

Interested in selling?

People are reaching out to these agents in Westerville for a market analysis.

Patrick Murphy

at Keller Williams Consultants

(128 reviews)

Get a market analysis

Leah & Lyss, I Care Home Group

at Cutler Real Estate | I Care Home Group

(44 reviews)

Get a market analysis

Elyssa Palyas

at Cutler Real Estate | I Care Home Group

(4 reviews)

Get a market analysis

Krista Kirkwood

at Coldwell Banker Realty

(29 reviews)

Get a market analysis

Nearby agents

Compare and contact these top performing agents who’ve delivered exception customer service for their clients in Westerville

Patrick Murphy

Sellers who recommend Patrick Murphy have praised them for being local expert, responsive, clear communication, supportive, well-prepared, friendly, and reliable

5 (128 reviews)
3 Reviews in Westerville
4 Sales in Westerville

View profile

Leah & Lyss, I Care Home Group

Leah & Lyss, I Care Home Group is a recommended agent for Westerville. They have 4 local sales and collected 2 local reviews across the last 12 months.