5251 Route 44

Amenia NY 12501

2022 sq. ft.

146797 sq. ft.

Single-Family

Last sold for $645,000

Brian McGrath, last sold this property on 06 February 2026 after 140 days on market.

Overview

The TRIFECTA, a rare offering that unites a contemporary three-story residence, a private inground pool, and a remarkable 3,500 SF steel barn privately sited at the back of the property. Set on 3.37 acres along Route 44, just minutes from the heart of Amenia, this property blends lifestyle and business potential in one extraordinary package. The property's centerpiece is the most incredible steel barn, previously an automotive shop, stands as the crown jewel for any tradesperson, hobbyist, or entrepreneur. This 70 x 50 structure boasts two oversized garage doors, 22 foot ceilings at the center, an office, a combination laundry room and bathroom, propane heat, a separate water meter with hot and cold water, its own septic system, and ample parking tucked far from the road. Zoned for Office/Commercial/Industry Mixed-Use, the barn opens endless possibilities for light industry, retail, service businesses, warehousing, or trades like auto repair, landscaping, contracting, tree services, or agriculture—a true field of dreams for those with vision. The home itself is a fantastic opportunity for restoration, offering the perfect canvas to bring its great bones and unique character back to life. This 2,882 SF three-story residence boasts dramatic peaks, vaulted ceilings, and wide pine flooring waiting to be revitalized. The home's layout is open and spacious, with an interior balcony and a catwalk that add to its distinctive charm. On the ground level, you'll find a rec room, a den or office, a full bathroom, and access to the two-car garage. The main floor features an open-concept dining room, kitchen, and breakfast area with a door that leads to the side deck and pool area. A super-sized living room with great windows and a cozy wood-burning stove provides the perfect spot to relax. This level also includes a laundry room with a door to the back deck and two equal-sized bedrooms with a full bathroom. The top floor is a private primary suite with a vaulted ceiling, two closets, and a bathroom with a large tub and shower. The catwalk leads to an attic with plenty of storage. Outside, the property shines with its vast yard space, ideal for recreation or relaxation, and the pool area serves as a private oasis for summer days. Whether you’re an artist, collector, or professional tradesperson, this property is a one-of-a-kind opportunity to live, work, and create in a setting that blends modern potential with timeless appeal.

Features

3 bedrooms

3 bathrooms

10 carspaces

10 garage spaces

2022 sq. ft. floor area

146797 sq. ft. lot size

Single-Family

Estimated Value

Based on this property and similar 3 bedroom single-family properties sold in Amenia over the last 12 months, the estimated median property value of 5251 Route 44 is $495k.

Median value

$495k

Estimated value range

$371k - $6.18m

Median days on market

Estimated value trend

23%

increase over the last 12 months

Average days on market is based on recent, comparable sales in Amenia. It is only an indication of the time a property is actively listed and should not be relied upon as an accurate representation of how soon a property will be sold.

Property history for 5251 Route 44

2026

Sold

$645,000

06 Feb 2026 by Brian McGrath, of McGrath Realty Inc.

Happy sellers in Amenia

We have insufficient information to provide an overview of customer satisfaction for Amenia. Viewing the agent profiles, reviews and sales for Amenia can provide insights for this location.