Back 423 E Tugalo St
Active

423 E Tugalo St

Toccoa GA 30577

5
4
4130 sq. ft.
0.63 ac.
Single-Family
Currently for sale - view listing

Overview

Buyers financing issues brings this lovely home back on market. Preferred lender is Katie Ledford Oconee Federal. 706-886-2111. In house or portfolio lender required likely due to guest home. In-town Country Living, a rare offering beautiful downtown Toccoa property zoned B-1 that offers stately historic home fronting 423 E. Tugalo St and a fully equipped guest house fronting 423 E. Savannah St. Toccoa GA. This idyllic setting is what city planners strive for as they try to recreate the perfect neighborhood or town setting. Great neighborhoods host a mix of uses in order to provide for our daily need to live, work, play, worship, dine, shop, and talk to each other. Walk along tree lined streets and enjoy living and working in historic downtown Toccoa where generations of professionals and executives have called home. Zoning allows each residence to be used as a home or office or a combination of both. Nearby Toccoa Falls College, various medical facilities, as well as tourist destinations create a big demand for short term rentals (present owners use the guest home for short term rental). Well maintained, this is a very unique property. The original home was built in 1905, the same year the Stephens County courthouse was constructed. It has been well preserved over the years. Consisting of four rooms boasting 11a ceilings, 2 fireplaces and plaster walls, youall want to ask about several aoriginal-to-the-propertya items. Two major additions have been made to the original home. In 1998, while keeping the faAade of the original home intact, the original porch was replaced with a permanent poured concrete flooring across the front and wrapping around the west side of the home. Older additions were removed from the rear of the home, being replaced by a primary bedroom suite, guest bathroom, open dining/kitchen-/sunroom, utility laundry and substantial pantry space. The existing central hallway from the front door was continued through to the rear door, maintaining the ashotguna architecture of the home. The 11a ceilings throughout the home offer a spacious feel to the home. In 2010 the next major addition to the home consists of a complete 2 bed/2 bath ain-law suitea with itas own open living room, kitchen and laundry. The second bed/bath lofted suite overlooks the living area providing connection but privacy. The in-law, or Guesthouse as it has been called, connects to the main home via a large covered breezeway. It provides a quiet, inviting space for early morning coffee, lunch with the family, or get together with family and friends. A large screen TV would add the final touch for viewing those sports events! Side note: In recent years the Guesthouse has been a popular ahome away from homea for Airbnb and Vrbo guests. The income from this nearly passive income can greatly offset any mortgage, utility or other expenses of the homeowner. A custom wood and wire custom fence encloses the backyard and a separate large outbuilding. Fresh landscaping complements the many mature pecan, walnut, live oak and water oak trees that complement the ain-town countrya feel of the property. The two car brick carport and covered walkway provide a convenient covered access to the main home, breezeway and in-law suite for bringing in the groceries. The property has secure access from Savannah Street and the First Baptist Church parking to the rear. Thereas so much more to add given the location of this desirable property. Historic downtown Toccoa, Paul Anderson Park, the Norfolk Southern Railway depot, Stephens County History & Currahee Military Museum, historic Stephens County courthouse, Stephens County Little League fields, Toccoa Clinic, city and county government buildings, U.S. Post Office and several churches are all within walking distance. Itas a quick few minutes drive to the Stephens County hospital, Stephens County Recreation facilities, LeTourneau Airport, Lake Hartwell, golf and additional shops and restaurants.

Features

5 bedrooms
4 bathrooms
4130 sq. ft. floor area
0.63 ac. lot size
Single-Family

Happy sellers in Toccoa

84%
84% of sellers in Toccoa reported that their sale price either exceeded or met their price expectations.

Toccoa stands out for consistently delivering exceptional satisfaction and strong market results for homeowners.

This is based on voluntary sentiment collected from 5 reviews in Toccoa over the last 12 months.

Local market activity for 5 bedroom single-family properties in Toccoa

In the last 12 months, 14 five-bedroom single-family properties similar to 423 E Tugalo St, have been sold.

This represents a 30% increase in five-bedroom single-family properties sales when compared to the previous 12 months.

© 2026 RateMyAgent