38 Plattekill Avenue

New Paltz NY 12561

2800 sq. ft.

13939.2 sq. ft.

Duplex

Last sold for $785,000

Emily Benazzi, last sold this property on 17 April 2026 after 305 days on market.

Overview

Turn-of-the-century duplex located directly across from SUNY New Paltz in the heart of the village—an exceptional opportunity to own a high-performing, income-generating property in one of the Hudson Valley's most sought-after locations. This beautifully maintained home features a spacious two bedroom apartment on the first floor, currently listed at 2,500/month, and six individual bedrooms upstairs, each rented at 905/month, (including al utilities) sharing two full bathrooms and a well-appointed kitchen—ideal for student housing or co-living. Perfect as a turnkey investment or potential owner-occupied residence with strong supplemental income. Tenants enjoy shared coin-operated laundry in the basement and limited off-street parking. A two-story garage offers significant potential for future expansion, studio space, or additional revenue. Perfectly positioned within walking distance to restaurants, coffee shops, boutiques, world-class dining, and the vibrant arts and culture scene of New Paltz, with easy access to NYC, Mohonk Preserve, and the Shawangunk Mountains. Rarely does a property offering this level of location, character, flexibility, and income potential come to market.

Features

8 bedrooms

3 bathrooms

2 carspaces

2 garage spaces

2800 sq. ft. floor area

13939.2 sq. ft. lot size

Duplex

Estimated Value

We need at least 3 similar 8 bedroom duplexes sold in New Paltz over the last 12 months.

Property history for 38 Plattekill Avenue

2026

Sold

$785,000

17 Apr 2026 by Emily Benazzi, of VORO, LLC

2025

Rented

Undisclosed

24 Jul 2025 by VORO, LLC

2023

Sold

$650,000

16 Mar 2023 by Susan Mattsen, of Keller Williams Hudson Valley

Happy sellers in New Paltz

We have insufficient information to provide an overview of customer satisfaction for New Paltz. Viewing the agent profiles, reviews and sales for New Paltz can provide insights for this location.