258 Bay Walk

Off Market

258 Bay Walk

Fire Island NY 11782

2300 sq. ft.

7841 sq. ft.

Single-Family

Last sold for $1,275,000

David Sanders, last sold this property on 06 February 2026 after 186 days on market.

Overview

Fire Island Pines. A Bayfront Original with Elevated Potential. Welcome to Clamalot, a bay-front classic with a name as unforgettable as its setting. Perched high on a dune and accessed by a private bridge from Bay Walk, this 5-bedroom, 3.5 bath beach house sits above the flood zone and offers panoramic views of the Great South Bay. Built in 1974 and held by the same family ever since, Clamalot is a true original, full of character, privacy, and possibility. From the lion’s head knocker to the hand-lettered nameplate on the gate, every detail hints at the home’s storied past and one-of-a-kind charm. Inside, a multi-level layout offers room to gather or retreat, with a full-floor primary suite and sliders opening to a private bayview balcony. Main living and dining areas connect to multi-tiered decks ideal for entertaining. Outside, enjoy a decked-in pool with a new liner, and an updated Navy-style bulkhead—ready for kayaks, paddle-boards, and sunset sails. While the home awaits your vision and updates, its foundation is rare: high elevation, water frontage, and a legacy of single ownership. Clam-a-Lot isn’t just a house—it’s a Fire Island original, ready for its next chapter.

Features

5 bedrooms

4 bathrooms

2300 sq. ft. floor area

7841 sq. ft. lot size

Single-Family

Estimated Value

Based on this property and similar 5 bedroom single-family properties sold in Fire Island over the last 12 months, the estimated median property value of 258 Bay Walk is $815k.

Median value

$815k

Estimated value range

$520k - $1.27m

Median days on market

Estimated value trend

-5%

decrease over the last 12 months

Average days on market is based on recent, comparable sales in Fire Island. It is only an indication of the time a property is actively listed and should not be relied upon as an accurate representation of how soon a property will be sold.

Property history for 258 Bay Walk

2026

Sold

$1,275,000

06 Feb 2026 by David Sanders, of Compass Greater NY LLC

Happy sellers in Fire Island

We have insufficient information to provide an overview of customer satisfaction for Fire Island. Viewing the agent profiles, reviews and sales for Fire Island can provide insights for this location.

Local market activity for 5 bedroom single-family properties in Fire Island

In the last 12 months, 4 five-bedroom single-family properties similar to 258 Bay Walk, have been sold.

This represents a 62% increase in five-bedroom single-family properties sales when compared to the previous 12 months.

Sold

For Sale

Interested in selling?

People are reaching out to these agents in Fire Island for a market analysis.

Julie Poidomani

at Realty Connect USA L I Inc

(38 reviews)

Get a market analysis

Brian Connor

at Realty Connect USA L I Inc

(1 review)

Get a market analysis

Sean Manning

at Realty Connect USA L I Inc

(7 reviews)

Get a market analysis

Evelyn Danko

at Summer Place Realty

Get a market analysis

Nearby agents

Compare and contact these top performing agents who’ve delivered exception customer service for their clients in Fire Island

Julie Poidomani

Julie Poidomani is an award winning recommended agent for Fire Island. They have 2 local sales and collected 1 local review across the last 12 months.