RateMyAgentGo to search
Back 2540 Sutton Avenue
Off Market

2540 Sutton Avenue

Carmel IN 46032

5
4
2
5201 sq. ft.
25700 sq. ft.
Single-Family
Last sold for $675,000
Natalie ClaytonNatalie Clayton, last sold this property on 09 October 2026 after 41 days on market.

Overview

Back on Market - Buyer Denied Financing | A Spacious (5,200+ SqFt) & Classic Carmel Custom Build In Huntington Chase - Next to Coxhall Gardens and West Park - And a 10 Minute Bike Ride to Village of WestClay Shops and Restaurants | You'll appreciate the .6ac lot, primary bedrooms on both the main and upper floors (five total bedrooms), generous main floor office, solid wood doors and trim and the enormous, finished basement. | Investments: Water heater: 2026. Interior/exterior painting: 2026. Built-in oven & microwave: 2026. New electric stove top: 2024. Heat Pump AC: 2022 (w/ 10yr warranty with Thiele). Water softener, sump pump w/ batter back up and garage door opener: 2021. Furnace: 2018 (15yr warranty and serviced 2x/year by Thiele). New Anderson Windows: 2017. Architectural dimensional 30yr roof: 2010. Home has a 5-stage RO water filter drinking system, too. Don't miss your chance to call this house your home.

Features

5 bedrooms
4 bathrooms
2 carspaces
2 garage spaces
5201 sq. ft. floor area
25700 sq. ft. lot size
Single-Family

Estimated Value

Based on this property and similar 5 bedroom single-family properties sold in Carmel over the last 12 months, the estimated median property value of 2540 Sutton Avenue is $1.1m.

Median value
$1.1m
Estimated value range
$350k - $3.71m
Median days on market
6
Estimated value trend
17%
increase over the last 12 months
Average days on market is based on recent, comparable sales in Carmel. It is only an indication of the time a property is actively listed and should not be relied upon as an accurate representation of how soon a property will be sold.

Property history for 2540 Sutton Avenue

2026
Sold
$675,000
09 Oct 2026 by Natalie Clayton, of Maywright Property Co.

Happy sellers in Carmel

92%
92% of sellers in Carmel reported that their sale price either exceeded or met their price expectations.

Carmel stands out for consistently delivering exceptional satisfaction and strong market results for homeowners.

This is based on voluntary sentiment collected from 12 reviews in Carmel over the last 12 months.

Local market activity for 5 bedroom single-family properties in Carmel

In the last 12 months, 112 five-bedroom single-family properties similar to 2540 Sutton Avenue, have been sold.

This represents a 9% increase in five-bedroom single-family properties sales when compared to the previous 12 months.

Nearby agents

Compare and contact these top performing agents who’ve delivered exception customer service for their clients in Carmel

placeholder
Jennil Salazar

Sellers who recommend Jennil Salazar have praised them for being local expert, responsive, reliable, clear communication, honest, and strategic

  •   5   (29 reviews)
  •  6 Reviews in Carmel
  •  32 Sales in Carmel
View profile
placeholder
Bif Ward

Bif Ward is an award winning recommended agent for Carmel.  They have 21 local sales and collected 3 local reviews across the last 12 months.

  •   5   (24 reviews)
  •  3 Reviews in Carmel
  •  21 Sales in Carmel
View profile
placeholder
Haiyan Gong

Haiyan Gong is an award winning recommended agent for Carmel.  They have 3 local sales and collected 2 local reviews across the last 12 months.

  •   5   (13 reviews)
  •  2 Reviews in Carmel
  •  3 Sales in Carmel
View profile
placeholder
Chas Schaffernoth

Chas Schaffernoth is an award winning recommended agent for Carmel.  They have 2 local sales and collected 1 local review across the last 12 months.

  •   5   (10 reviews)
  •  1 Review in Carmel
  •  2 Sales in Carmel
View profile
or
Skip the list and find your ideal agent to sell your propertyFind My Agent
RateMyAgent
Sales:
(619) 566-0008
Company
AboutCurrent JobsBrand Guidelines
Help & Learning
Tools and TipsHelp CenterBlog
Product
Compare AgentsTracked PropertiesSalesPlans & PricingLoginJoin
Community
Awards
Quick Links
© 2026 RateMyAgent
Privacy PolicyTerms & ConditionsLicensingSitemap