131 East Chestnut Street

Off Market

131 East Chestnut Street

Lancaster OH 43130

4284 sq. ft.

3484.8 sq. ft.

Single-Family

Last sold for $387,900

Jenifer Campbell, last sold this property on 12 November 2025 after 119 days on market.

Overview

Find your sanctuary in this one-of-a-kind home! Originally build in 1851 as Emmanuel Lutheran Church, later known as the B'Nai Israel synagogue, and is currently a converted private residence. This versatile open-concept design offers 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a large kitchen with a walk-in pantry, a generous recreation room complete with pool table. This historical property blends preserved architectural elements with modern living features including gothic stained-glass windows throughout, arched church doors, soaring vaulted ceilings, original hardwoods, and a bell tower. Perfect for artists, musicians, or continue as Airbnb revenue. Minutes from downtown's vibrant art galleries and museums, coffee shops and restaurants. If you're looking for a property with profound history, architectural beauty, and endless creative potential, make your appointment today!

Features

4 bedrooms

2 bathrooms

4284 sq. ft. floor area

3484.8 sq. ft. lot size

Single-Family

Estimated Value

Based on this property and similar 4 bedroom single-family properties sold in Lancaster over the last 12 months, the estimated median property value of 131 East Chestnut Street is $351.25k.

Median value

$351.25k

Estimated value range

$45k - $2.2m

Median days on market

Estimated value trend

increase over the last 12 months

Average days on market is based on recent, comparable sales in Lancaster. It is only an indication of the time a property is actively listed and should not be relied upon as an accurate representation of how soon a property will be sold.

Property history for 131 East Chestnut Street

2025

Sold

$387,900

12 Nov 2025 by Jenifer Campbell, of Howard Hanna Real Estate Servc

2021

Sold

$338,000

10 Jun 2021 by Lisa McKivergin, of REMAX Town Center | Columbus

Happy sellers in Lancaster

93%

93% of sellers in Lancaster reported that their sale price either exceeded or met their price expectations.

Lancaster stands out for consistently delivering exceptional satisfaction and strong market results for homeowners.

This is based on voluntary sentiment collected from 31 reviews in Lancaster over the last 12 months.

Local market activity for 4 bedroom single-family properties in Lancaster

In the last 12 months, 145 four-bedroom single-family properties similar to 131 East Chestnut Street, have been sold.

This represents a 29% increase in four-bedroom single-family properties sales when compared to the previous 12 months.

Sold

For Sale

Interested in selling?

People are reaching out to these agents in Lancaster for a market analysis.

Kimberly Cumbo

at Key Realty

(59 reviews)

Get a market analysis

Jamie Rohr

at Key Realty

(65 reviews)

Get a market analysis

Holli Jones

at Realty ONE Group Refined | Carroll

(42 reviews)

Get a market analysis

Siara Kopis

at Real of Ohio

(26 reviews)

Get a market analysis

Nearby agents

Compare and contact these top performing agents who’ve delivered exception customer service for their clients in Lancaster

Kimberly Cumbo

Sellers who recommend Kimberly Cumbo have praised them for being clear communication, local expert, dedicated, patient, supportive, responsive, and attentive