RateMyAgentGo to search
Back 1251 Lancaster Avenue
Off Market

1251 Lancaster Avenue

Reynoldsburg OH 43068

4
2
1
1577 sq. ft.
14374.8 sq. ft.
Single-Family
Last sold for $275,000
Michelle BrooksMichelle Brooks, last sold this property on 17 February 2026 after 25 days on market.

Overview

Welcome home to the perfect blend of historic charm and modern comfort in this beautiful property just moments from the heart of Uptown Reynoldsburg. Inside, you'll find thoughtful updates paired with timeless character, starting with the inviting first floor featuring arched doorways, new lighting, LVP flooring, and fresh paint throughout. The beautifully updated kitchen features granite counters, tiled backsplash, crisp white cabinets, and SS appliances. The spacious dining room flows to a warm, welcoming living room anchored by a decorative fireplace with beautiful wood surround. Upstairs, the second floor hosts three charming and beautifully finished bedrooms, a large, updated full bath, and heirloom hallway built-ins. Hardwood floors add richness and warmth throughout this level. The third floor provides a versatile fourth bedroom complete with charming built-ins and exposed brick, making it a perfect retreat, guest space, or creative studio. The basement adds even more potential with a second decorative fireplace and a convenient half bath—ideal for future finishing or for use as generous storage. A bright 3-season room offers serene views of the expansive backyard—lined by the peaceful Blacklick Creek and backing to the 26 acre John F Kennedy Park complete with baseball fields, tennis courts, playground, picnic facilities, and trail that connects with Huber Park. With convenient location just feet from the vibrant Uptown Reynoldsburg, a picturesque natural setting, and a home full of character and updates, this property is truly one-of-a-kind.

Features

4 bedrooms
2 bathrooms
1 carspace
1 garage space
1577 sq. ft. floor area
14374.8 sq. ft. lot size
Single-Family

Estimated Value

Based on this property and similar 4 bedroom single-family properties sold in Reynoldsburg over the last 12 months, the estimated median property value of 1251 Lancaster Avenue is $350k.

Median value
$350k
Estimated value range
$145k - $658.03k
Median days on market
14
Estimated value trend
-1%
decrease over the last 12 months
Average days on market is based on recent, comparable sales in Reynoldsburg. It is only an indication of the time a property is actively listed and should not be relied upon as an accurate representation of how soon a property will be sold.

Property history for 1251 Lancaster Avenue

2026
Sold
$275,000
17 Feb 2026 by Michelle Brooks, of Red 1 Realty
2020
Sold
$180,000
20 Jul 2020

Happy sellers in Reynoldsburg

90%
90% of sellers in Reynoldsburg reported that their sale price either exceeded or met their price expectations.

Reynoldsburg stands out for consistently delivering exceptional satisfaction and strong market results for homeowners.

This is based on voluntary sentiment collected from 8 reviews in Reynoldsburg over the last 12 months.

Local market activity for 4 bedroom single-family properties in Reynoldsburg

In the last 12 months, 193 four-bedroom single-family properties similar to 1251 Lancaster Avenue, have been sold.

This represents a 27% increase in four-bedroom single-family properties sales when compared to the previous 12 months.

Nearby agents

Compare and contact these top performing agents who’ve delivered exception customer service for their clients in Reynoldsburg

placeholder
Mindy Back

Sellers who recommend Mindy Back have praised them for being supportive and empathetic

  •   5   (25 reviews)
  •  2 Reviews in Reynoldsburg
  •  2 Sales in Reynoldsburg
View profile
placeholder
Stephen Dial

Stephen Dial is a recommended agent for Reynoldsburg.  They have 1 local sale and collected 2 local reviews across the last 12 months.

  •   5   (128 reviews)
  •  2 Reviews in Reynoldsburg
  •  1 Sale in Reynoldsburg
View profile
placeholder
Molly A Mosley

Sellers who recommend Molly A Mosley have praised them for being local expert, clear communication, responsive, supportive, reliable, honest, and trustworthy

  •   5   (119 reviews)
  •  2 Reviews in Reynoldsburg
  •  1 Sale in Reynoldsburg
View profile
placeholder
Mike Jovanovic

Mike Jovanovic is an award winning recommended agent for Reynoldsburg.  They have 1 local sale and collected 2 local reviews across the last 12 months.

  •   5   (38 reviews)
  •  2 Reviews in Reynoldsburg
  •  1 Sale in Reynoldsburg
View profile
or
Skip the list and find your ideal agent to sell your propertyFind My Agent
RateMyAgent
Sales:
(619) 566-0008
Quick Links
© 2026 RateMyAgent
Privacy PolicyTerms & ConditionsLicensingSitemap