1 Elm Street

Cooperstown NY 13326

3612 sq. ft.

0.17 ac.

Single-Family

Last sold for $489,000

Denise Page La Cava, last sold this property on 26 October 2026 after 136 days on market.

Overview

Step into over two centuries of history with this distinguished 1810 Federal-style home, lovingly owned by the same family for 58 years. Nestled in Cooperstown's coveted Historical Village, this residence offers 5 bedrooms, all on the second floor, with good-sized closets, and 3 baths, plus a spare room on the first floor, which was previously used as a first-floor bedroom with a 3/4 bath perfect for guests, multi-generational living, or a home office. The home's interior exudes classic Federal charm. A graceful main staircase welcomes you into a space rich with character, while a back staircase offers convenient access to the upper floors. The centerpiece fireplace anchors the living areas, providing warmth and a sense of home. Throughout the home, beautiful parquet and wide-plank flooring highlight its early craftsmanship and enduring quality. The large kitchen serves as the heart of the home, ideal for daily life, family gatherings, and entertaining. Outside, the yard features some unique millstone that offers a serene retreat for gardening, play, or quiet reflection, preserving the property's historic charm. Original details and period architecture are celebrated throughout, blending seamlessly with a functional layout that accommodates modern living. While it requires updating, including a new roof, this residence presents a rare opportunity to restore a piece of Cooperstown history and create a lasting legacy. With its combination of historic character, family heritage, and prime village location, this home invites the next owner to continue its story, preserving its timeless charm and creating memories for generations to come. A short walk from Bassett Medical Center, the Clark Sports Center, fine restaurants, unique shops, the National Baseball Hall of Fame, Otsego Lake, and the Otesaga Hotel. A short drive brings you to the Fenimore Art Museum, Glimmerglass Festival, and Glimmerglass State Park. Beyond its charm and convenience, this home is situated in a friendly neighborhood renowned for its rich history, local events, and small-town character.

Features

5 bedrooms

3 bathrooms

1 carspace

1 garage space

3612 sq. ft. floor area

0.17 ac. lot size

Single-Family

Estimated Value

Based on this property and similar 5 bedroom single-family properties sold in Cooperstown over the last 12 months, the estimated median property value of 1 Elm Street is $660k.

Median value

$660k

Estimated value range

$489k - $1m

Median days on market

105

Estimated value trend

15%

increase over the last 12 months

Average days on market is based on recent, comparable sales in Cooperstown. It is only an indication of the time a property is actively listed and should not be relied upon as an accurate representation of how soon a property will be sold.

Property history for 1 Elm Street

2026

Sold

$489,000

26 Oct 2026 by Denise Page La Cava, of Stack-Page Properties

Happy sellers in Cooperstown

We have insufficient information to provide an overview of customer satisfaction for Cooperstown. Viewing the agent profiles, reviews and sales for Cooperstown can provide insights for this location.